Which Bakery to use?

Which Bakery to use?

Which Bakery would you choose?
Our catering hall uses either Create a Cake bakery or The Rolling Pin for the wedding cake.
I keep reading reviews and both are 50-50 either way. Which would you go with?
Do you have any personal experience with either one? Please share!
TIA Girls!!!!!

Re: Which Bakery to use?

I have had cakes from both. I chose the Rolling Pin. They both make beautiful cakes but taste wise I would go with Rolling Pin... JMHO..... HTH

Re: Which Bakery to use?

yearsss ago, we had a cake made for my cousin's bridal shower. it was from create a cake and they copied her bridal shower invite perfectly. the cake was adorable and tasted great, and they're affiliated with benkert's. however, rolling pin is a bit more high end and i've bought from there too, and their cakes i think maybe taste just a bit better.