Which one do you think looks best?

So after my makeup trial yesterday, I went home and looked at the pictures from my sister's wedding. I don't wear makeup usually so I think the eye makeup from the trial is too dramatic and a little too much. I think the makeup for my sister's wedding was more natural.

What do you think?

Edited to say I am going for a natural look so the makeup trial won't look like I have much makeup on. Just wondering if that would look fine or should I spice it up?