Who has followed the females on American Idol?

LImom Posted: Feb 22, 2005 11:48 PM

Who has followed the females on American Idol?

I can't recall which girl sang the title song from Fanthom of the Opera for her audition. She had an amazing voice and I'm wondering if she was one of the 12 competing tonight.

Thanks.

mrswask Posted: Feb 22, 2005 11:49 PM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

They didn't move her on once she got to Hollywood. SHe had an incredible voice - totally gave me the chills!

Butterflybride Posted: Feb 22, 2005 11:49 PM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

Posted by LImom

I can't recall which girl sang the title song from Fanthom of the Opera for her audition. She had an amazing voice and I'm wondering if she was one of the 12 competing tonight.

Thanks.

Unfortunately she didn't make it. I thought her voice was amazing as well.

LImom Posted: Feb 23, 2005 12:15 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

That night I remember them telling her should would have to sing rock. Maybe that wasn't her style. I can't believe she didn't make it, though. A few sounded flat tonight.

maybride2004 Posted: Feb 23, 2005 06:15 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

I couldn't stand the girl that thought she knew it all! I forget her name. She was horrible
But loved the girl Carrie she was fantastic!

1017Bride Posted: Feb 23, 2005 06:23 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

Mikaylah is so annoying and a bit fake
too.
Carrie is sweet and talented and real.

barb04 Posted: Feb 23, 2005 07:11 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

Carrie is my favorite girl so far, she sounded great last night!

Dom n Nic Posted: Feb 23, 2005 08:24 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

Posted by LImom

I can't recall which girl sang the title song from Fanthom of the Opera for her audition. She had an amazing voice and I'm wondering if she was one of the 12 competing tonight.

Thanks.

she had crazy pink hair very punk rock
but she did not make it this far -i think she was cut last week

Dom n Nic Posted: Feb 23, 2005 08:25 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

Posted by 1017Bride

Mikaylah is so annoying and a bit fake
too.
Carrie is sweet and talented and real.

she sounds just like taylor dane(if thats how you spell her last name lol)

CaCRmr Posted: Feb 23, 2005 08:27 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

I don't like Makayla (spell?) or her voice. I enjoyed listening to Carrie Underwood. I am looking forward to the elimination tonight.

KathleenG Posted: Feb 23, 2005 08:33 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

I thought Carrie was great; she really carried the song very well. Am I the only one that kinda likes Mikayla? She is extremely bubbly and perky but she does have personality, which is lacking this season IMO. They are a talented bunch (more so the boys than girls) but nobody is blowing me away with personality. Maybe they are too nervous at this point. They look like soooo nervous this year.

Boop2704 Posted: Feb 23, 2005 08:40 AM

Re: Who has followed the females on American Idol?

I like Carrie, she has a beautiful, natural voice!! I liked Nadia too.

Some of them need to pick better songs, I am sooo tired of the slow songs. There are so many songs out there and they always pick the Celine and Whitney songs!!

Did anyone notice the girl in the green halter dress? I swear, I thought she was going to fall off the stage she was sooo nervous!!

Mikalah is my least favorite. I think she is so fake and soo dramatic and too high schooly. I tired of her prom threats to Simon. And her lips, omg could they have anymore collogen stuffed in them. She sounds like a cruise ship singer to me!!