I'm hoping I remember everything, and if anyone has questions, please feel free to FM me. The day was beautiful, and I had a great time!
Bridgeview Yacht Club: A+ Kathy and Mike were a pleasure to work with. They accomodated my requests, and they were pretty good about returning my calls in a timely manner.
My guests said the food was excellent, and the cocktail hour (I was told) was magnificent as well. I had a Mickey/Minnie theme, and the chef (Miguel) carved the melons into Mickey and Minnie and carved a pumpkin into Cinderella's coach. He also carved a bouquet of flowers out of vegetables b/c I'm allergic to flowers. He did beautiful work!
The bridal attendant was very efficient. My only gripe with her was that she seemed more concerned with rushing me along to meet the timeline than anything else (she even took me away from guests when I was talking to them). That I did NOT like at all! Overall, she got us whatever we needed and was on top of things.
Ric Mango Orchestra B+ We got many compliments from our guests about the band. I personally noticed that they were not playing more than they were, but if no one else noticed, that's what matters! Their music was good, though I regret not spending more time sitting with Ric to discuss SPECIFICALLY what songs I wanted played - my fault. I did mention a few, but he didn't play them all. Also, it was pointed out to me that during the breaks, they played the same CD and some guests actually heard the same song THREE different times! All in all, Ric did get people to dance, got them going and he wasn't obnoxious at all. But I definitely do NOT think we got our money's worth (they were expensive).
Jack and Rose F I was VERY disappointed with Jack and Rose and regret my decision wholeheartedly! After meeting with Jack for over two hours at 9:00 at night, he DIDN'T even do the work for my wedding (though he indicated that HE WOULD be doing it). After sending in our deposit, I didn't hear from Jack EVEN ONCE - NOT EVEN to this day! He pushed us off on his co-worker in the Queens shop (who did a very sloppy job), and I was truly disappointed. Also, NO ONE (not Jack or Patty) showed up at my church or my hall on my wedding day - only a deliveryman. Additionally, I have grave issues with his business ethic as a whole. If anyone wants details, please FM me.
Perceptions Photography B+ Got proofs back, and they look very nice! Overall, Anthony and Leslie were very pleasant. My only negative comment is that based on other brides' posts about their photographers, mine didn't stay with me the 'typical' amount of time or until the end of the reception, but I have to check my contract to make sure that is accurate.
Bridal Reflections Massapequa B- My dress was beautiful, but I wasn't pleased with the seamstresses work (forgot her name). My dress was falling down in the front a little as the day went on (no, I hadn't lost weight - lol). I also was very annoyed with the nasty attitudes of the night time people at the front desk when I went for my fittings. They were very rude and only cared about how much you had to pay. My final complaint was that when I went to pick the dress up, I made the mistake of NOT taking the whole dress out (I just looked at the parts that I knew needed to be altered). When I got home (to Bayside), there was a stain on the side/back that I hadn't seen. I then had to go back the next day to have them remove it. They insinuated that it was me who must have stained it!
Simply Elegant - Invitations A+++ Gail was wonderful! She gave me good prices and was patient with all my font changes. She got the invitations (and then extra response) cards in a VERY timely manner. She is great to work with and very professional and friendly!
Christy and Co. Bayside - Hair/Makeup C- My hair/makeup came out okay, but I was appalled at the rudeness and disorganization of the people at the front desk. They did NOTHING to accomodate the 'bride' on my wedding day. I asked for water, and they told me they didn't have it - that I could go a few stores down if I wanted it!! Then they made me wait a half hour in between hair and makeup (even though I DID have an appointment). VERY RUDE!!!
Ultimate Class Limos A+ No complaints at all! Requested Janice, and she was wonderful! Two towncars home were great too and all of the drivers were excellent and friendly!
Royal Brass A+++ Wonderful as well! Scott was very professional and helpful from the first phone call to the last time we spoke at church. They were wonderful, and it was a pleasure to work with them!
Murphy & Co. - Florist A++++++++ I had to go to them for my silk bouquet (I'm highly allergic to flowers), because Jack and Rose could not accomodate me (FM me for more detailed info). Kevin was wonderful! He did EXACTLY what I wanted (even better), and the flowers did NOT look even one bit fake! I absolultely loved loved loved them! He was great to work with and didn't insist that I get real flowers or make me feel funny for asking for silk ones. He understood my dilema, and was professional, accomodating and friendly. Also, he didn't try to 'sell' himself. His work speaks for itself. I should have gone to him for all my flowers. ALWAYS follow your gut instinct!!
I'd like to thank all the girls for their advice and ideas - especially Marcellabella!!!
Please FM if you want any further details.
larryswife2be
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
I am sorry to hear about J&R, but I am glad you had a great day overall
JimmysBride
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Hmmm.... I grow more and more skeptical of this board when I read this kind of stuff.... I sincerely hope this thread does NOT get removed.
Thanks for the honest review minnie and congrats on your marriage!
minniebride14
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Thanks SOO much, you guys!!
wenndypoo
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Minniebride I personally appreciate your honest review. We need to know the good and the bad when it comes to vendors, and your experience will help other brides by pointing them to areas of weakness that their vendors may have, and help improve the service. IMO, everyone benefits. I'm sorry people chose to bring drama to your thread because of your honesty. I think we invest so much in our weddings and vendors, that we take it personally when someone doesn't feel the same way about them.
Congrats again, and much love in your new marriage!
The Original 2nd-time-around
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congrats on your day, and sorry you had some difficulty.
As far as the vendor thing goes, some people like a certain vendor and some don't. Everyone is entitled to their opinions
August04
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Posted by 2nd-time-around
Congrats on your day, and sorry you had some difficulty.
As far as the vendor thing goes, some people like a certain vendor and some don't. Everyone is entitled to their opinions
I agree, everyone has their opinions and are entitled to sharing them.
Congratulations, hope you had a wonderful day despite the mishaps.
nj42305
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congrats Minnie
kaangel217
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congrats. I hope to see your pictures soon. I also liked the fact that you gave an honest review.
LImom
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congratulations and thanks for an honest review.
The Original 2nd-time-around
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
I really don't think that what was said was slander at all, just an opinions WITHOUT being too harsh.
She also saw their work at another wedding that she didn't like, so again, it's her opinion and her decision
minniebride14
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
I posted an honest review, b/c that is exactly what I was looking for when I was planning my wedding. Most importantly though, you need to go with your gut; I didn't on a few decisions, and I learned my lesson the hard way.
Mary, overall, the dress was totally fine - really! It was just falling down in the front/side a little as the night went on (it was strapless). I just found that I had to keep pulling it up - nothing really major though. It was more annoying than anything; it wasn't as if the dress was going to fall off! Honestly, I think they probably have more than one. Just ask. And, don't worry!
MrsERod
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
minniebride...CONGRATULATIONS!!! You seem to be a class act that refuses to stoop to other peoples levels...I am fairly 'new' to these boards, and I dont know what to make of all this B.S. that's going on...I DO know that you gave an HONEST review and should be commended... IMO I have seen some rather 'less than flattering' pics of girls who've gone for makeup consults, and instead of jumping on the bandwagon and saying how 'gorgeous' or 'stunning' they look just because its a popular or well liked vendor, (even though one girl looked like she had clumps in her lashes)... i say nothing! the other girls are right for thanking you for an honest review...at least you're not being phony!...honesty is ALWAYS the best policy.. again, congratulations, and best wishes for the future!
AUG21-04
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
ROFLMFAO!!! Not to be funny but with this ring can u FM me and tell me what that means?
minniebride14
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Thank you Christina!!
Misty
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congrats Minnie!!! And welcome back!
butterfly91804
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congrats Minnie - thanks for the honest review
june262004
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
groovypeg
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
I am a bride using 3 of minniebride's vendors: photographer, florist and bridal salon.
I am not worried one bit about how they will perform on my day. I did alot of research on my vendors and yes, the good outway the bad. But I expect that every vendor will have negative reviews. One person's experience is not enough to form my own opinion.
For the ladies considering booking Jack, you should go and meet him and make up your own mind.
ETA: Everyone is entitled to express their opinions, good and bad. But don't let one negative review prevent you from meeting with a potential vendor. I seriously freaked when I heard a negative review for one of my potential vendors-but when I met with them I had a great experience and booked them on the spot. Minnie bride expressed an opinion.
Everyone's experiences will be different.
Peace!
babybride
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Congrats and sorry for the mishaps, but it still sounds like a wonderful day!!!
04Bride
Thread views: 17,908
Member since
Re: My November 2 Wedding Review
Isnt it possible for two people to have two DIFFERENT experiences with a vendor? i mean this is way out of hand. this is not what LIW is suppose to be about. This is why i think the boards have been rather slow( at least before this post they were) latley. People should be allowed to post good and bad. i havent gotten married yet so i havent posted a review but I did post my dress when i was considering buying it and alhough no one had an out and out bad comment about it some people had comments that some may not consider flattering and i didnt get crazy i just took it and considered it and still bought the dresss. If someone is considering JnR and they read this it will just give them another opinion to consider before booking. What is so bad abuit that!!!! JMO