OOT Bachelorette Party

A few girlfriends and I have spent the last few weeks trying to (unsuccesfully) plan my out-of-town bachelorette party.

We definitely want to go April 15-18 and want to ideally do Puerto Rico (San Juan) or Jamaica (maybe Negril). There are 8-9 of us. We want something safe, but don't want to stay anywhere family-oriented and really want to party (location within walking distance to clubs, bars, restaurants).

We looked into a few resorts in PR and then thought it might make more sense to rent a vacation home or villa where we could all stay together, but are concerned about the sketchiness of it.

I am looking for potential vacation rentals in PR or any suggestions for other places to go (I was just in the DR and Mexico so those are definitely out, and I think that Bermuda would be too cold and Bahamas too family-oriented).