Post New Topic

Advice needed!

lizzzie35 Posted:

Advice needed!

Warning: Longish Post Ahead!

So, I've mentioned this before but I am not a religious person by any means but FH wants to get married in the church where he received his sacraments (even though the only times he has ever been inside a church in the 7 years I've known him were for his niece and nephews christenings!). I have (well, had) no problems with this. I always thought I would like a church wedding.

Well, first off, my dad is Jewish and when I told him about the ceremony being in a church he was a bit taken aback. Secondly, we found out that the earliest a ceremony could take place would be 11:30 because they do funerals at 10. Well, I want(ed) an afternoon wedding and any RH in our (my dad's) price range that I like has afternoon ceremonies taking place at either 12 or 12:30 and there is no way we would make it there on time from the church! Thirdly, we went to see the Deacon who would be marrying us last night and we got a booklet where we have to choose which passages, psalms, etc. that we want read for each part of the ceremony. I was a bit freaked out when reading them! I knew it would be a religious ceremony but whoa!!! Also, the Deacon kept mentioning that if I ever wanted to be baptised that he would be more than happy to do that for me.

So, now I'm thinking that this church wedding thing may not be such a great thing for me after all. I keep thinking about my dad and his whole side of his family and how uncomfortable they will be watching their non-religious Cathowish (my own religion ) daughter, granddaughter, niece, etc. pledge to raise her children Catholic and so on and so forth. And I am feeling sort of uncomfortable with that as well. Also, the cost of the wedding to make it a saturday night would just skyrocket and I know my dad would have a problem paying not only $30-$40 more pp (about 150 ppl) for a night reception but also the $775 for the church fee!

I'm not sure what I should do. FH keeps reminding me that the church is the only thing he cares about and says that I could choose absolutely everything else from decorations to flowers to music to menu. But I am starting to feel uncomfortable with the idea of it being so religious. So, I told him, if he wants it so bad, he has to ask his parents to put up the money not only for the church but for the extra cost for a night wedding. But I don't know! I'm so confused!

Sorry so long!
yngcpl92203 Posted:

Re: Advice needed!

Hmm tough situation. You both need to agree on something that will make you both happy. I defintely think he needs to be told how you are feeling. Maybe he will be understanding of your feelings and your families. It is hard when you have your heart and mind set on something. I hope you two can work something out. After all it is yours and his wedding. Good Luck.

Danip24 Posted:

Re: Advice needed!

Why not compromise? My sister's husband is Jewish and they were going to have a church wedding. Then he felt uncomfortable with is family. So they decided to get married at C.W. Post chapel. It is an interfaith chapel. They had a deacon and a cantor and it was an amazing ceramony. Everyone was happy and it was quite unique??? I hope this is helpful.

I can understand what you are saying about having it in church. We are both catholic and we went last Sunday to book our church. It is very overwhelming.
he gives me butterflies Posted:

Re: Advice needed!


Posted by Danip24

Why not compromise? My sister's husband is Jewish and they were going to have a church wedding. Then he felt uncomfortable with is family. So they decided to get married at C.W. Post chapel. It is an interfaith chapel. They had a deacon and a cantor and it was an amazing ceramony. Everyone was happy and it was quite unique??? I hope this is helpful.

I can understand what you are saying about having it in church. We are both catholic and we went last Sunday to book our church. It is very overwhelming.



i agree. try interfaith!
CNC4eva3402 Posted:

Re: Advice needed!


Posted by Danip24

Why not compromise? My sister's husband is Jewish and they were going to have a church wedding. Then he felt uncomfortable with is family. So they decided to get married at C.W. Post chapel. It is an interfaith chapel. They had a deacon and a cantor and it was an amazing ceramony. Everyone was happy and it was quite unique??? I hope this is helpful.

I can understand what you are saying about having it in church. We are both catholic and we went last Sunday to book our church. It is very overwhelming.



I agree completely!

You have to find a happy medium..if that seems to be one thing that is very important to FH, I would try to meet him somewhere in the middle on it..
Ann 52409 Posted:

Re: Advice needed!

The interfaith ceremony is a way to compromise but, if that doesn't work you could also let FH know that your dad is not willing to pay the extra for the one thing your FH wants so if he or his family can help with the extra cost of a night wedding then that will be a compromise.

lizzzie35 Posted:

Re: Advice needed!

Thanks everyone... just in case, does anyone have any recommendations on an officiant?

We're looking at more places today so we'll see how their prices are for day vs. night.

Thanks again!
FuTuRe MrS MaZz Posted:

Re: Advice needed!

FSIL is Catholic and married a Jewish guy and they had both a priest and rabbi... Dont know where it was held though... I would definately incorporate both... Do more research and im sure you can find a compromise
INNbride4409 Posted:

Re: Advice needed!

I would interfaith. A family friend recently had the GOD SQUAD and they were great and extremely funny.

Also if the church is something your FH will not change, could you possiblely look into a Friday night so the price would be a little cheaper?

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.