Post New Topic

Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

SoontobeMrsH Posted:

Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

Ok so my brother bought my FH & I items off our registry Idk what to get him, I've bought him a Coach Wallet, passport case, belt, business card case, etc years past, and he's not really excited...

I got him a sweat suit from Abercrombie
and a standing punching bag.Would it be cheesy to box a key and write a tag saying he's such a key person to us, that we've booked a room for him at Glen Cove Mansion the night of our wedding?

His GF who is a BM also got a suit from Abercrombie, idk what else to get them? I'm stumped
DCLM726 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

I think that the key would be cute.

mathteach Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

yeah, I want to be related to you...

bella1028 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

the key idea is so unique...i love it
SoontobeMrsH Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed


Posted by mathteach

yeah, I want to be related to you...



Thanks, I was just going to give them the matching Abercrombie sweat suits & him the punching bag... but he bought us this off our registry which was very generous and I'm glad my mom said something to me that way we can give equally. you know

The second pic won't show it's the Simply Stainless Calphalon 10 piece pots & pans set.


My brother is also my dietition, Starting January 1st I am going on a stict diet to get my desired wedding body so that could be why he choose to get us this...
babieblueeyez96 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

not a bad gift giver at all! the key idea is cute :)

angl2001 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed


Posted by bella1028

the key idea is so unique...i love it



yeah!
jonsgirl04 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

Looks to me your an awesome gift giver!!!
CNC4eva3402 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

I love the key idea! I think you are a GREAT gift giver. If you still feel like you wanted to do a little extra..why not buy their fav. champagne or liquor and have it chilled in the room before they get there for the nite? I love extra little touches!

Toucan311 Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

Michele, you are SUPER gay
AndRecKy Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

thats an awesome gift (the key thing) i would love it! im sure he and his gf would too!!!
RKellner Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed

I think the key thing is adorable!
I like it alot, very different and much more meaningful!
SoontobeMrsH Posted:

Re: Am I a bad gift giver? Opinons needed


Posted by RKellner

I think the key thing is adorable!
I like it alot, very different and much more meaningful!



Thanks surfing this site, I saw a bride that did that with stds, she's the NYE Oheaka '07 . I wasn't planning on spending that, but he out did himself. I wasn;t sure if paying for their room at the mansion for our wedding would be weird as part of a Christmas gift.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.