bridal shower question

So a while back I decided instead of doing a wishiing well I wanted to do something a little different and ask that each guest bring a non perisable item to put in the wishing well that I would bring to the church or soup kitchen to donate to the needy.........................fast forward to me and FH registering a few weeks ago I completley forgot about my Idea and registered for all kinds of 'wishing well items'

so my question is can I do both or do I just do my first idea and take some of the little things off my registry??

I would keep them on. People may add little things to their gifts.

I think for my shower people will be bringing recipes so I can start my cookbook? (No wishing well)