Picked 2 at random and decided to wear a light blue top (figured that would show any problems!)
The left pit is Lady Speed Stick Clean
The right pit is Secret Platinum Invisible
I got to work at 7:30 and decided I would check in with the products at 9:00, 12:00, 3:00 and 5:00.
I have a co-worker who is coming to the wedding who will help if any sniff tests are needed.
At 9:00:
The left pit (Lady Speed Stick) is very dry and no marks - seems to smell fine
The right pit (Secret Platinum) is also perfectly dry and mark free at this point, smell is excellent
Stay tuned...
TwoBugs
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
As a scientist, I'm very impressed with the meticulous nature of this experiment. You are truly doing a service to humanity.
MrsK-in-June05
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
this has to be the funniest post in awhile!! loves it! keep us updated!!
FallBride2004
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
Final check in for the day...
Lady Speed Stick:
No White Marks (Score 10/10)
Small Sweat Circle some wet feeling (Score 6/10)
Odor Rating by co-worker (Score 7/10)
Total Score for the day: 23
Secret Platinum Invisible:
No White Marks (Score 10/10)
No Sweat Marks and total dryness (Score 10/10)
Odor Rating by co-worker (Score 9/10)
Total Score for the day: 29
Secret wins for the day, rematch tomorrow.
Esor
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
Posted by FallBride2004
Final check in for the day...
Lady Speed Stick:
No White Marks (Score 10/10)
Small Sweat Circle some wet feeling (Score 6/10)
Odor Rating by co-worker (Score 7/10)
Total Score for the day: 23
Secret Platinum Invisible:
No White Marks (Score 10/10)
No Sweat Marks and total dryness (Score 10/10)
Odor Rating by co-worker (Score 9/10)
Total Score for the day: 29
Secret wins for the day, rematch tomorrow.
This is too funny. I agree with the poster above who prefers the 'cream' like formulas to the gels. I always feel like I have wet underarms with the gels - I don't think it ever drys.
I say you need to use them under the same underarms and not switch. Maybe it needs a cumulative effect?
azoodie
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
OMG I AM ROLLING ON THE FLOOR!!!!!!!!!!!!
that was one of the funnies things i've ever seen on here!!! bravo to you!!!
KelOct04
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
Posted by FallBride2004
Noon Check in:
Lady Speed Stick:
No odor No white marks No sweat marks
Secret Platinum
No Odor No White Marks No Sweat Marks
3:00 Check in (With the co-worker)
Lady Speed Stick
No White Marks One tiny sweat mark Sniff Check - 'Not bad, no BO but no scented smell either'
Secret Platinum
No White Marks No Sweat Marks Sniff Check - 'Smells fine, very nice'
Slight lead for the Secret Platinum at this point
I am going to use these same 2 tomorrow, switching pits
This is too funny!!! But very informative.. thank you!!
akaMrsT
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
Posted by FallBride2004
Final check in for the day...
Lady Speed Stick:
No White Marks (Score 10/10)
Small Sweat Circle some wet feeling (Score 6/10)
Odor Rating by co-worker (Score 7/10)
Total Score for the day: 23
Secret Platinum Invisible:
No White Marks (Score 10/10)
No Sweat Marks and total dryness (Score 10/10)
Odor Rating by co-worker (Score 9/10)
Total Score for the day: 29
Secret wins for the day, rematch tomorrow.
LOL LOL LOL
I use Secret Platinum & really like it. I never had a problem with it.
I was told that women should switch up every 6 months or so since our bodies get used to a particular brand. I don't switch up often - unless I run out and end up using leftover Dove.
Blu-ize
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
I think that you have way too much time on your hands!!! Although, it is a great service to us all and I appreciate it.
PK2BE
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
See this is why we need this board! My FI has been my 'research assistant' in the quest for the perfect deodorant. He got sick of seeing the white marks from the gel deodorants. I just switched back to Secret Platinum cream. How does the Mitchum solid/cream work? I don't like the gel.
May05Bride
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
marc_rai
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
Are you an industrial engineer? I must say you designed a wonderful unibiased experimental approach. The only problem might be if you tend to sweat more under one armpit than the other. Oh gosh, I'm too anal.
marc_rai
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
I used to use Lady Mitchum (Powder Fresh). Now I use the male Mitchum (Fresh Clear Gel). It's the best. No white marks, but I have to be careful not to put on my clothes immediately after applying it.
bluesashbride
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
this is so funny! i'm so glad i found this chat board!
my 2 cents for deodorant...i use the new addidas and LOVE it! never been drier!!! haha though that i'm enthusiastic today about DEODORANT!!!
hbradio
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
This is the best! I honestly appreciate it!!! Are you going to try any more brands? How about the Certain Dri one?
FallBride2004
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
For Today Switched Armpits and will use the same end of day scoring methods
I've been thru the 1st 2 checkups of the day and they went well for both sides - but the 3:00 is coming up quickly and the co-worker is ready to roll
be back soon!
MrsNYPDsGirl
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
Posted by FallBride2004
For Today Switched Armpits and will use the same end of day scoring methods
I've been thru the 1st 2 checkups of the day and they went well for both sides - but the 3:00 is coming up quickly and the co-worker is ready to roll
be back soon!
Ohhh the anticipation is killing me!
RobNette
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
YEah...this rules!
I might have to do my own ...since my body is so tempermental with products!
But thank you for doing us all a service and posting your findings!!!
This is great!
we are such girls! I told my FH about this thread..and he just shook his head. I'm lucky if he REMEMBERS deoderant that day!
JK
Darcy
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
we are such girls! I told my FH about this thread..and he just shook his head. I'm lucky if he REMEMBERS deoderant that day!
Yeah! My FH thinks we are aweful. I think it is great. I hadn't even worried about it until now. Glad this little experiment is going on :)
Chrissa
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
This is so funny!! I can't wait for the results. This will definatly influence my next trip to Wal-mart! Maybe I'll give the winner as favors! Aahahahaha
With your official report attached of course!
suezboss
Posted:
Member since
Re: First of the Deodorant Tryouts today - read on...
