Does anyone wish that the judges voted instead of the public?
As much as a PITA SImon is.. hes usually pretty right and think they would be more fair. this show stinks.
Espo22
Posted:
Member since
Re: idol? POLL!!
at this point i say the judges... I LOVE Simon
ShanonandSteve
Posted:
Member since
Re: idol? POLL!!
i LOVE Simon too!
DavaDay
Posted:
Member since
Re: idol? POLL!!
I also love Simon. But this is 'American Idol,' not '3 Judges' Idol.' The reason it's so popular is that people feel like they have a hand in deciding who the next superstar should be. If the judges picked, then it wouldn't get half the ratings it does.
Luvbsb4eva
Posted:
Member since
Re: idol? POLL!!
Sometimes I wish the judges had more of a say, because they are usually right. If anyone watched that Grease: You're the One That I Want show it was kinda a combination of both... the viewers would vote and they would list the final 2, and then the judges would decide who they were saving! Maybe then American Idol would be a little more on the right track and the really talented contestants would move on.
