Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Original post by Jen2999
OK.. I just got in from the diner and saw katherine
She was good.... but I miss Chris
Jen2999
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
OMG Im watching regis and kelly and he is talking so nice about his wife
Chelle
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
I was trying for an hour and I got through ONCE for Taylor.
Wintersbride
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
I'm sorry, I really do not like Taylor...he reminds me of a really bad wedding singer and he looks like Jay Leno. That was one of the worst versions of 'You Are So Beautiful' I have ever heard in my life. I'm sorry, I know I am a minority. I actually like Kat. If she does not win the competition, she definitely has a shot for broadway. To be honest, not too impressed w/ the final 3. None seem to idol-ish. Ok, that's my critique...I was only watching to pass time until House came on anyway, so I guess it should not matter.
chloeme2
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by greenfreak
Simon's comments really made it sound like he was saying goodbye to Elliot, did you notice that? That thing about his Mom being proud?
And how can he think that Elliot's 'You Are So Beautiful' was his best performance? His voice was cracking on the low notes and it was a boring song.
The more I see stuff like this, the more I smell a fix.
I agree. It seems like Simon wants Taylor to win.
VadersBride2006
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by chloeme2
Posted by greenfreak
Simon's comments really made it sound like he was saying goodbye to Elliot, did you notice that? That thing about his Mom being proud?
And how can he think that Elliot's 'You Are So Beautiful' was his best performance? His voice was cracking on the low notes and it was a boring song.
The more I see stuff like this, the more I smell a fix.
I agree. It seems like Simon wants Taylor to win.
Which is odd, considering if you go back to the auditions, Simon told Taylor 'no' and said he didn't belong in the spotlight, he belonged in the background.
greenfreak
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Simon has been bashing Taylor all along, he didn't want him in the competition, he called him a bad karaoke singer or bad wedding singer more than twice. That's why I smell fix, because all of a sudden, Simon is commending him on at least one performance that was terrible.
sami
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
OMG I want to Taylor to win! He just seems so down to earth but all 3 are great!
greenfreak
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
I can't help but smile, watching him perform. I don't think he has a powerhouse voice but he's entertaining to us at least.
I just wish he would stop yelling SOUL PATROL! throughout Ryan's phone number bit. Then again, who wants to listen to Ryan Seacrest??
Happybride2005
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by sami
OMG I want to Taylor to win! He just seems so down to earth but all 3 are great!
with last nights performance, he's in the finals
BlueTulip
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by greenfreak
Posted by Jackie&Justin
I think Taylor will win it. Even though Katherine was good tonight, she was horrible most other nights. Taylor has been consistently good. I also like Elliot, but he doesn't have enough personality to win.
I agree. I thought her last song was screechy. Why does she always have to go overboard like that? The second song was her best.
I actually got chills when Elliot sang 'Try a Little Tenderness'. I've loved that song ever since I saw The Committments years ago.
Wasn't it Taylor that sang 'Try a little tenderness'?
Chelle
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by BlueTulip
Posted by greenfreak
Posted by Jackie&Justin
I think Taylor will win it. Even though Katherine was good tonight, she was horrible most other nights. Taylor has been consistently good. I also like Elliot, but he doesn't have enough personality to win.
I agree. I thought her last song was screechy. Why does she always have to go overboard like that? The second song was her best.
I actually got chills when Elliot sang 'Try a Little Tenderness'. I've loved that song ever since I saw The Committments years ago.
Wasn't it Taylor that sang 'Try a little tenderness'?
Yes, it was Taylor.
Chelle
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
I posted this on another post in response to a girl who didn't understand why Taylor is still where he is and continued to be voted through to the next round.... And without my man Chris around anymore I'm voting for Taylor all the way.
'I am a huge fan of Taylors. I think he's an entertainer and I feel that's what appeals to the public. He commands a crowd, he makes people smile, he get's the crowd involved, up and dancing, he has an insane personality that's infectious and he's a good singer. He's VERY unique. I think in a world of cookie cutter singers and bands, he stands out on his own, he's original and different and I think he's refreshing!'
greenfreak
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
You said it Chelle!! Couldn't have said it better myself.
glinda_goodwitch
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by chloeme2
Posted by greenfreak
Simon's comments really made it sound like he was saying goodbye to Elliot, did you notice that? That thing about his Mom being proud?
And how can he think that Elliot's 'You Are So Beautiful' was his best performance? His voice was cracking on the low notes and it was a boring song.
The more I see stuff like this, the more I smell a fix.
I agree. It seems like Simon wants Taylor to win.
I've been saything this for a while! But I thought they were trying to boot Katherine so Chris would win.
Chelle
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by greenfreak
You said it Chelle!! Couldn't have said it better myself.
THANKS!! (I try )
JanuaryBride06
Posted:
Member since
Re: Im sadly posting the OFFICIAL American IDOL thread-clive davis
Posted by Jen2999
Posted by JanuaryBride06
Posted by alnem
did you guys chris daughtry on ellen degeneres this morning? he was so cute playing his guitar!
