Jeff Lubin or Peter Duchin Bands?

As promised, I would report back after our band appointments. We saw a representive from Hank Lane and James Faith, both played us cds of their recommended bands. They based their reccomendation on our music taste and the overall feel we wanted for our wedding. Hank Lane suggested The Jeff Lubin band. James Faith suggested The Duchin band or some other that we did not like. Both establishments were very professional and helpful. This is such a big decision for us, and we want to make the right choice! We are leaning to the Jeff Lubin band for several reasons- it is the Carlyle's house band/ first recommendation, and they are a set band who have been together for years. At James Faith we were played a wonderful cd, but we were not sure who was playing on each song(the singers changed), and we had t keep asking 'is this Holly singing now?'. We also don't know if we should look further into other bands to see what else is out there...we already looked at Franklin Wayne's selection and The Times Square Orchestra. If anyone has any suggestions that they feel will help us out, please feel free! Thanks.