NWR: House Hunting Help!!!

Soooo FH isn't from around here and has been having some sticker shock in the house hunting department... We've narrowed down the towns we like but I was hoping you guys could recommend the towns you grew up in/live in/bought your house in...

Right now we're looking in Northport/East Northport, Huntington, Babylon, Oakdale, and Sayville.

Anyplace we should add? Anyplace that has a similar feel to those towns?