they are so similar!!! do you have any of you in the maggie? i like the detail on the top of the simone but i like the botton on the maggie
nope, not allowed to take any....my mom isn't slick enough to even sneak one
NanandEric08
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I voted for the Maggie...both are gorgeous but I like that the Maggie one has a little less going on in terms of layers on the bottom.
brittndave
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
Posted by Iluvpoodles
I'm going to be totally honest. The first one I feel like there is too much going on in the bottom. Too many layers. The top is pretty though.
ita ... i think the simone has too much going on so it just makes it look wrinkled and a little messy i guess. the maggie gives you the same look just with a little less so it's cleaner and more sophisticated looking! i voted for the maggie
latinaj
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
what abt the quality? color? feel? price?
they are very similar!
Future Mrs H
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I love the maggie! So pretty!
Jenna_and_John
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
Posted by brittndave
Posted by Iluvpoodles
I'm going to be totally honest. The first one I feel like there is too much going on in the bottom. Too many layers. The top is pretty though.
ita ... i think the simone has too much going on so it just makes it look wrinkled and a little messy i guess. the maggie gives you the same look just with a little less so it's cleaner and more sophisticated looking! i voted for the maggie
I do agree with this, I'm voting for the Maggie, plus it's my name! haha
Golden
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I prefer the Maggie. Still different but more elegant in my opinion.
Jtruran
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
go w/ the Maggie
Diana508
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
Both beautiful and very similar, but I think the Maggie has less going on and like it better for that reason.
GiannisWifey
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
price - both are below what I was intending to spend, which is great LOL so the price is not making my decision since they aren't 10k dresses lol
quality......both are silk tafetta
RGEC47
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I love the Maggie. The Simone is pretty but it has to much going on that it makes the dress look to busy. JMO!
Jenna_and_John
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
Posted by GiannisWifey
price - both are below what I was intending to spend, which is great LOL so the price is not making my decision since they aren't 10k dresses lol
quality......both are silk tafetta
Maggie all the way then! yay!
soonT0beMrsD
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I like the Maggie
Lsorrent
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I vote for the Maggie! I think the bottom is much softer looking
If you like the beading of the Simone up top, maybe they could add beading on top of the maggie?
Becca2010
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
You know how i feel...
Clover23
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
i like the maggie a lot better!
shelbylove918
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
typically I tend to draw my eyes more toward simone carvalli dresses.. but, in this case Im not loving this one.. to much goin on I think.. The Maggie is simpler and looks like its beautiful without being overwhelming.. I say def go with the Maggie.. im sure you look gorgeous in it:)
miamimerger
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
I like the maggie more. the ONLY reason i'm 51/49% on this is and not 50/50 is because of how the dress cuts off on your hips. though you have the body for BOTH (seriously), i think the maggie dress would be more flattering when you think of all the different angles pictures will be taken.
GiannisWifey
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
thanks ladies! i appreciate your honesty!
latinaj
Posted:
Member since
Re: Question
Posted by Lsorrent
I vote for the Maggie! I think the bottom is much softer looking
If you like the beading of the Simone up top, maybe they could add beading on top of the maggie?
