question about photo montage

I want to do a little something different for our photo montage...

FH & I want it to be funny...we have two ideas...

1) I'm kinda known as the crazy/funny one amongst my friends so I was thinking 'You May be Right' by Billy Joel and a bunch of funny pictures of me throughout the years. Then FH is a HUGE HUGE HUGE Yankee fan...so we were thinking 'New York New York' then pics of him in his baseball gear from when he was young. Then the third part would be the two of us together...pics of us both at Yankee games and pics of us both having fun.

2) A few years ago, we made a really funny music video to Bon Jovi's 'Bad Medicine'...so the other idea was to have maybe 3-4 baby pics...then have it come to a halt and show our 'Bad Medicine' video.

What do you like better and why?

#2!!! Because it's AWESOME!

#1 is still a nice idea, but more traditional. If you're gonna do it, might as well do it up right!

i don't think people would pick up on what you're trying to do with #1 unless you tell them. it is a very cute idea though.

i really like #2 - it sounds like a lot of fun and much more entertaiing than just pictures. just make sure it's funny to others, not just you guys - i have a video that 2 of my BMs and me made when we were young - we crack up anytime we watch it ... but others thing it's boring and stupid.

i'm not sure if this is feasible for you or not but one of my coworkers had a humorous video of him and his now-wife re-enacting how they met, the proposal, etc. They wore wigs and whatnot. everyone loved it

---

Posted by JAAMS

Sorry I keep bumping this...but I want to know what people think OR if people think both ideas are stupid since no one is responding.

---

i already responded, but if you want more people to answer, you should set it up as a poll so people can vote anonymously