My DH's b-day is coming up and I want to find a really romantic restaurant to go to, since its his first b-day as my husband...Any suggestions?
nov06
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Where in Suffolk?
ewickens
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
We love Mario's in Setauket.
LuvMyAlfonse
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Viva la Vida is a romantic mex place in oakdale....
nov06
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
The Gatsby - Islip The Bayport House - Bayport Trumpets by the Bay - East Moriches (I think)
ladybug78
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Posted by nov06
Where in Suffolk?
Anywhere in Suffolk.
ladybug78
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
I am looking for a place that won't be too crowded and has great food, with a romantic atmosphere!!
beachbum05
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Do you wanna shell out some cashola? If so, I highly recommend going to the Maidstone Arms or the Palm Restaurant in East hampton.
This time of year out there is SOOOOOOO romantic, and just has such a nice feel. Its SO cozy!!! i wanna go just thinkign about it!
D's Girl
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
I love Mill Pond in Huntington/Centerport
Right on the water and amazing food
kittythestray
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Posted by ladybug78
I am looking for a place that won't be too crowded and has great food, with a romantic atmosphere!!
We love La Plage in Wading River or Over Pasta in Miller Place. Both are small so you need reservations, La Plage is dressier & more expensive.
Bambubabe
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
For Italian I like Bella Vita in St James or Casa rustica in Smithtown. I like the Blue Honu...It's dark. For me Dark = Romance lol.
Bambubabe
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Oooh and the Grille Room in hauppauge. You've struck a nerve here...I love to eat.
ladybug78
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Thanks for all the suggestions ladies!!! We are so used to going to loud restaurants all the time so I want to do something different and do quiet, small and romantic...Please keep the ideas coming!
mrsh2b
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
The Bridge in West Islip is nice. We also like il villagio (I think?) in Babylon village. Another nice restaurant is Siempre Vivolo in Hauppauge on Motor Parkway. That's really quiet and romantic.
SoontobeMrsH
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Posted by nov06
The Gatsby - Islip The Bayport House - Bayport Trumpets by the Bay - East Moriches (I think)
the gatsby was voted the most romantic restaurant on long island by aol
lilqtpie2181
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
I know u said Suffolk but if u want a REALLY romantic place there is little place in the village called One if by Land Two if by Sea. OMG it is breathtaking. When I first went there... Fh was taking me for our 2 year aniv. and we walked by it 3 times.. it looked like a little garage form the outside. As soon as u walk in its like a differnt world. HIGH celings all hard wood candle lite only and live piano player. Just BEAUTIFUL!!!! If u want to take the ride is is def worth the trip.
EGreene79
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Posted by mrsh2b
The Bridge in West Islip is nice. We also like il villagio (I think?) in Babylon village. Another nice restaurant is Siempre Vivolo in Hauppauge on Motor Parkway. That's really quiet and romantic.
This might be closing. I drove by it yesterday, and it looked like they were changing the name and management.
nbc188
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
Posted by kittythestray
Posted by ladybug78
I am looking for a place that won't be too crowded and has great food, with a romantic atmosphere!!
We love La Plage in Wading River or Over Pasta in Miller Place. Both are small so you need reservations, La Plage is dressier & more expensive.
Oh, where is 'Over Pasta'? I live right near Miller Place, and haven't heard of it. But I need to now!!!
jtgarsik
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
another for bayport house :)
NF622
Posted:
Member since
Re: SWR-Most romantic restaurant in Suffolk?
The gatsby in Islip def. FH and I went there for a romantic dinner the night he proposed. You can sit on a couch together and eat or they have a little table set away from everyone in a little alcove that looks like a wine cellar. Very romantic!! The food is good, but pricey.
