Post New Topic

Update:Dont want to take his last name

Original post by MrsLarrea2B

For a traditional bride, I am having a hardtime accepting the idea of changing my last name. I feel like a) I am not his damn property. i am not his dog or his slave. b) why should I have to take his stupid last name? c) why should his 'family' take the credit for my accomplishments...d) why should I have to 'give up' my family history and my fathers last name for FH ??? e) Why should I have to go through the hassle of changing my last name and all legal documents????

I have argued w. people over this and all i hear is 'I dont want my kids to feel weird b.c we dont have the same last name. i dont want teachers to think my child is a ******* child. (LOL). so then if this is the case....why not take MY last name???
What the hell makes his damn family better than mine that I should feel so damn PRIVILEDGED to have it????? people have suggested hyphenating my name....I think thats stupid. what the hell am I supposed to do... Sign 3 damn names everywhere? i really hate the fact that women are even put in this stupid position. I thought about changing my middle name to his...or maybe change it to my last name (if I want to compromise) but i hear that I have to go through the supreme court to get ny middle name changed!!! ***?

*** MY SCREEN NAME IS Mrs.Larrea 2b --- I used it b.c I figured I would 'try' to get used to it. But the more ppl at work ask me 'so you are going to be Mrs.___' and I alwasy respond 'Mrs.hurtado' and they get all weirded out. then i get the 'ur a feminist' crap.

It is a matter of principle ... What the hell makes him king of the castle???

UPDATE 03/11/08


FH and I argued about it yesterday. He was so pissed off at me. He even brought up cancelling the wedding!
He asked me why I didnt want to change my name. I told him b.c I didnt see a need for it and my name meant a lot to me. He countered w. its tradition for the woman to change her name. SO me like an *** I said, I dont wanna follow tradition...and then my super smart sneaky FH double countered w. 'so why the hell are w. paying 30k for a wedding, if you dont wanna follow tradition???' ( Just to fill you in, FH is against us having a huge wedding. But he is doing this b.c he knows I have been dreaming of this day since I was born. My FH literally starves himself in order to pay for our wedding. He doesnt go out his friends, and if he does he always invites me to come along. from the moment we got engaged he immediately went along w. the wedding plans and didnt argue w. me about it)

So basically we are 2 very stubborn people, My argument is that the whole 'tradition' excuse is not a good reason and I dont wanna go that route. Which hapens to be HIS reason for not wanting a big wedding. Money is very important to him and he is willing to give it all to me to throw away on one day, instead of using that money to buy our 1st house together or opening up a business.

As far as the last name goes, his excuse is that it is tradition and he does want to go that route.
He feels that I am contradicting myself when I say 'I am traditional and I MUST have a huge wedding. BUt then again I am a modern woman and I dont care what people say so I wont take your last name'

So then I tried to reason w. him and brought up hyphenating.... he said 'no way, how about we have a 1/2 assed wedding then? or I only give you 1/2 the money? or 1/2 a wedding cake? All or nothing'

Then I said, FINE, then NOTHING!
We walked towards the car and started laughing. He turned to me and said... 'You have to take my last name, we are going to start a family'

I pretended not to hear him and the argument ended there. I am telling you, this is not going to be an easy one.



MrsLarrea2B Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsDrinkh20


'Well, whats the worse that can happen? By then I would have already given him the pleasure of taking his last name, so he will be happy. A few days after we get married I will go to the SS office and replace my middle name w. my maiden name. Then I will go home to DH and act all naive and happy and say 'Hey, guess what? I decided to change my middle name for my maiden name. ' - he will then get mad. and I will play stupid 'I didnt know this would bother you, I did take YOUR last name... well, what do I look like ... a mindreader??' - lol
and then eventually he will get over it, and we can have fun having make up sex. Whats he gonna do? Leave me??? '




Oh my goodness.>>i am trying to decide if this is some sort of joke! I really can't imagine having this attitude and lying this way to my future husband..I totally understand not wanting to take his last name (believe me) but I don't think lying about it and playing dumb is going to make anything easier...'whats the worst that can happen?' Him not trusting you and leaving? I think thats pretty bad!







lol. Come on!! He hasn't gone anywhere in 3 years, why would he leave now? Trust? I've travelled alone w. friends to Cancun, Japan, Punta Cana, Bahamas and Fl. I really dont think trust will be an issue. Hey, worst case scenerio...After all we spend on the wedding, he wont be able to afford a divorce. lol.
I hope you realize that I AM taking his last name. I would be replacing my middle w. my maiden name. i dont think its a big deal..although his stubborn *** will dissagree. but whatever.
MrsDrinkh20 Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name

I agree he shouldnt find it to be a big deal..I know my FH would be so hurt if i tried to do what you are thinking of doing...its just not right in my mind...but to each her own.

MrsLarrea2B Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by bluegreen08

What if you said.... FH, I know how important it is to you for me to take your name, so after a lot of thought I decided that I am going to do that. However, my name is an important part of me and my family history, so I am going to drop my middle name and replace it with my maiden name.

Then live happily ever after?





Yeah but what if he still says no??? Then I cant go on w. my little plan of playing 'dumb'. lol
bluegreen08 Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsLarrea2B


Posted by bluegreen08

What if you said.... FH, I know how important it is to you for me to take your name, so after a lot of thought I decided that I am going to do that. However, my name is an important part of me and my family history, so I am going to drop my middle name and replace it with my maiden name.

Then live happily ever after?





Yeah but what if he still says no??? Then I cant go on w. my little plan of playing 'dumb'. lol



Then you talk to him and explain why doing this is the best compromise to preserve what is important to both of you........
IrishBrideASmiling Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name

I completely understand what you are talking about. My friend and I were discussing this not too long ago and she is in the same boat as you. She feels that she has had her last name for 26 years and why should she give it up?

I on the other hand love the idea of being Mr. and Mrs and having the same last name. I tend to be very traditional and am looking forward to it but I know its going to be difficult. It almost feels like you are giving up who you are but I know a last name change will not change who I am. Ive also been going back and forth with hyphenating my last name too.

If you are more comfortable keeping your name then you should. Its a part of who you are and a part of your family.
MrsDtoBe09 Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsDrinkh20


'Well, whats the worse that can happen? By then I would have already given him the pleasure of taking his last name, so he will be happy. A few days after we get married I will go to the SS office and replace my middle name w. my maiden name. Then I will go home to DH and act all naive and happy and say 'Hey, guess what? I decided to change my middle name for my maiden name. ' - he will then get mad. and I will play stupid 'I didnt know this would bother you, I did take YOUR last name... well, what do I look like ... a mindreader??' - lol
and then eventually he will get over it, and we can have fun having make up sex. Whats he gonna do? Leave me??? '




Oh my goodness.>>i am trying to decide if this is some sort of joke! I really can't imagine having this attitude and lying this way to my future husband..I totally understand not wanting to take his last name (believe me) but I don't think lying about it and playing dumb is going to make anything easier...'whats the worst that can happen?' Him not trusting you and leaving? I think thats pretty bad!






If my fh was planning something to lie to me about after we're married and then 'play dumb' about, I would immediately seek a divorce. Planning a lie is a bad bad idea. This will blow up in your face if you go through with it.

I know we probably all sound like biitches to you right now but we're really all trying to help you.
MrsLarrea2B Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by bluegreen08


Posted by MrsLarrea2B


Posted by bluegreen08

What if you said.... FH, I know how important it is to you for me to take your name, so after a lot of thought I decided that I am going to do that. However, my name is an important part of me and my family history, so I am going to drop my middle name and replace it with my maiden name.

Then live happily ever after?





Yeah but what if he still says no??? Then I cant go on w. my little plan of playing 'dumb'. lol



Then you talk to him and explain why doing this is the best compromise to preserve what is important to both of you........




I will try
MrsLarrea2B Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsDtoBe09


Posted by MrsDrinkh20


'Well, whats the worse that can happen? By then I would have already given him the pleasure of taking his last name, so he will be happy. A few days after we get married I will go to the SS office and replace my middle name w. my maiden name. Then I will go home to DH and act all naive and happy and say 'Hey, guess what? I decided to change my middle name for my maiden name. ' - he will then get mad. and I will play stupid 'I didnt know this would bother you, I did take YOUR last name... well, what do I look like ... a mindreader??' - lol
and then eventually he will get over it, and we can have fun having make up sex. Whats he gonna do? Leave me??? '




Oh my goodness.>>i am trying to decide if this is some sort of joke! I really can't imagine having this attitude and lying this way to my future husband..I totally understand not wanting to take his last name (believe me) but I don't think lying about it and playing dumb is going to make anything easier...'whats the worst that can happen?' Him not trusting you and leaving? I think thats pretty bad!






If my fh was planning something to lie to me about after we're married and then 'play dumb' about, I would immediately seek a divorce. Planning a lie is a bad bad idea. This will blow up in your face if you go through with it.

I know we probably all sound like biitches to you right now but we're really all trying to help you.



Yeah, but how is he supposed to know that I had it planned this whole time?
MrsDrinkh20 Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsLarrea2B


Posted by MrsDtoBe09


Posted by MrsDrinkh20


'Well, whats the worse that can happen? By then I would have already given him the pleasure of taking his last name, so he will be happy. A few days after we get married I will go to the SS office and replace my middle name w. my maiden name. Then I will go home to DH and act all naive and happy and say 'Hey, guess what? I decided to change my middle name for my maiden name. ' - he will then get mad. and I will play stupid 'I didnt know this would bother you, I did take YOUR last name... well, what do I look like ... a mindreader??' - lol
and then eventually he will get over it, and we can have fun having make up sex. Whats he gonna do? Leave me??? '




Oh my goodness.>>i am trying to decide if this is some sort of joke! I really can't imagine having this attitude and lying this way to my future husband..I totally understand not wanting to take his last name (believe me) but I don't think lying about it and playing dumb is going to make anything easier...'whats the worst that can happen?' Him not trusting you and leaving? I think thats pretty bad!






If my fh was planning something to lie to me about after we're married and then 'play dumb' about, I would immediately seek a divorce. Planning a lie is a bad bad idea. This will blow up in your face if you go through with it.

I know we probably all sound like biitches to you right now but we're really all trying to help you.




Im just curious...would it bother you if you found out he planned to lie about something to you after the wedding? I mean, if it wouldnt then I could see why this isnt a big deal fo ryou...but i am honestly so baffled at how you could see this as a good idea to start out your marriage! (Im not trying to be mean, im just trying to undersatnd...)

Yeah, but how is he supposed to know that I had it planned this whole time?
MrsDtoBe09 Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsLarrea2B


Posted by MrsDtoBe09


Posted by MrsDrinkh20


'Well, whats the worse that can happen? By then I would have already given him the pleasure of taking his last name, so he will be happy. A few days after we get married I will go to the SS office and replace my middle name w. my maiden name. Then I will go home to DH and act all naive and happy and say 'Hey, guess what? I decided to change my middle name for my maiden name. ' - he will then get mad. and I will play stupid 'I didnt know this would bother you, I did take YOUR last name... well, what do I look like ... a mindreader??' - lol
and then eventually he will get over it, and we can have fun having make up sex. Whats he gonna do? Leave me??? '




Oh my goodness.>>i am trying to decide if this is some sort of joke! I really can't imagine having this attitude and lying this way to my future husband..I totally understand not wanting to take his last name (believe me) but I don't think lying about it and playing dumb is going to make anything easier...'whats the worst that can happen?' Him not trusting you and leaving? I think thats pretty bad!






If my fh was planning something to lie to me about after we're married and then 'play dumb' about, I would immediately seek a divorce. Planning a lie is a bad bad idea. This will blow up in your face if you go through with it.

I know we probably all sound like biitches to you right now but we're really all trying to help you.




Yeah, but how is he supposed to know that I had it planned this whole time?


I think you really need to stop and think about this logically. A deliberate and planned lie sounds so horrible to someone looking from the outside in. If this is something you really are adament about and he will not respect it I think you have bigger issues.

Also, dont for a SECOND think that ANYTHING you write on here is private. How you do know his sister/friend's gf/mother/cousin/or anyone else is not reading this at this very moment.

All I'm saying is be very very very careful.
MrsLarrea2B Posted:

Re: Update:Dont want to take his last name


Posted by MrsDtoBe09


Posted by MrsLarrea2B


Posted by MrsDtoBe09


Posted by MrsDrinkh20


'Well, whats the worse that can happen? By then I would have already given him the pleasure of taking his last name, so he will be happy. A few days after we get married I will go to the SS office and replace my middle name w. my maiden name. Then I will go home to DH and act all naive and happy and say 'Hey, guess what? I decided to change my middle name for my maiden name. ' - he will then get mad. and I will play stupid 'I didnt know this would bother you, I did take YOUR last name... well, what do I look like ... a mindreader??' - lol
and then eventually he will get over it, and we can have fun having make up sex. Whats he gonna do? Leave me??? '




Oh my goodness.>>i am trying to decide if this is some sort of joke! I really can't imagine having this attitude and lying this way to my future husband..I totally understand not wanting to take his last name (believe me) but I don't think lying about it and playing dumb is going to make anything easier...'whats the worst that can happen?' Him not trusting you and leaving? I think thats pretty bad!






If my fh was planning something to lie to me about after we're married and then 'play dumb' about, I would immediately seek a divorce. Planning a lie is a bad bad idea. This will blow up in your face if you go through with it.

I know we probably all sound like biitches to you right now but we're really all trying to help you.




Yeah, but how is he supposed to know that I had it planned this whole time?



I think you really need to stop and think about this logically. A deliberate and planned lie sounds so horrible to someone looking from the outside in. If this is something you really are adament about and he will not respect it I think you have bigger issues.

Also, dont for a SECOND think that ANYTHING you write on here is private. How you do know his sister/friend's gf/mother/cousin/or anyone else is not reading this at this very moment.

All I'm saying is be very very very careful.


You are right, I should delete this post to erase any evidence.

-KIDDING- LOL. I am just having fun w. all of you, you know the same way you BS w. ur girlfriends, and usually ur girlfriends cheer you on...even though they know you are not gonna do.
it. Anyway, in my crazy mind I think that would be the easiest thing to do. But I dont think I will get away w. it either. lol

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.