who won tonite on American Idol?

groovypeg Posted: Feb 11, 2004 09:32 PM

who won tonite on American Idol?

i was out to dinner and i missed it!!!

Bride2be03 Posted: Feb 11, 2004 09:58 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

the show was great, I hope you enjoyed your dinner...
Jasmine won (the 1 who sang last, last night)

and

I forgot her name but she was the youngest (16 YRS old) and the first one to sing last night.

SomedayBride Posted: Feb 11, 2004 10:06 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

Fantasia

And Diana

Bride2be03 Posted: Feb 11, 2004 10:08 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

now i really feel like an idiot, i had the name wrong

IrishTracy Posted: Feb 11, 2004 10:08 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I'm so glad that Diana was voted in. She is an amazing singer!!

groovypeg Posted: Feb 11, 2004 10:17 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

yay!!!!!!!!!!!

i voted for both of them last nite!!!!!!!!!!!!

Bride2be03 Posted: Feb 11, 2004 11:19 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

me too

allure Posted: Feb 11, 2004 11:41 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

They both deserve it they are awesome

yabbobay Posted: Feb 12, 2004 02:23 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I love Diana too!!!

and while I can fantasia has talent...I was annoyed by 'schumting to talk about'

04Bride Posted: Feb 12, 2004 07:55 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

yeah i think fantasia was good but she had an annoying sound to her voice at times.

LOVE DIANA and she is ONLY 16!!!

Danielle&Scott Posted: Feb 12, 2004 07:57 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I cannot believe Katie didnt win....but I am happy Diana won....She is the next american idol

Lunatrek Posted: Feb 12, 2004 08:35 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I love Diana!

Could do without Fantasia... I was hoping for Katie. O well.... maybe in the wild card episode!

LizD Posted: Feb 12, 2004 08:45 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I know he didn't sing his best, but I really wanted Marque to go to the next round

julz33 Posted: Feb 12, 2004 08:46 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

Posted by yabbobay

I love Diana too!!!

and while I can fantasia has talent...I was annoyed by 'schumting to talk about'

I was thinking the same thing about fantasia!

IrishTracy Posted: Feb 12, 2004 08:52 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

Posted by julz33

Posted by yabbobay

I love Diana too!!!

and while I can fantasia has talent...I was annoyed by 'schumting to talk about'

I was thinking the same thing about fantasia!

I agree! I think she can sing!! But I wouldn't want to listen to that voice for a whole album!!

nrvbrd Posted: Feb 12, 2004 09:48 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I hope Diana goes all the way!!!

She has some set of pipes on her.

Suzanne Posted: Feb 12, 2004 09:51 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I dont like Fantasia AT ALL.. shes just mimicing Macy Grey.. Whats so different about someone who sounds exaclty like someone else?

And on a side note, I know its great that Randy is loosing all the weight, but i think he doesnt look healthy anymore...

nrvbrd Posted: Feb 12, 2004 09:58 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

Posted by Suzanne

I dont like Fantasia AT ALL.. shes just mimicing Macy Grey.. Whats so different about someone who sounds exaclty like someone else?

And on a side note, I know its great that Randy is loosing all the weight, but i think he doesnt look healthy anymore...

Suzanne, you are so right about Randy, enough is enough alreadt with the weight.

OctBride03 Posted: Feb 12, 2004 10:02 AM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

Suzanne I agree with you about Fantasia, I DO NOT understand how she got more votes than Diana!!! The judges are doing the same thing they did with Ruben (I didn't like him either)... Fantasia has a great personality, but voice, um... I don't think so.

Maybe I just don't know what the judges are looking for. I think Diana BLOWS her away!

ETA: I did think Ruben's voice was good, but I thought Clay should've won. Like I said I guess I don't know what the judges are looking for.

Tammy5-03 Posted: Feb 12, 2004 06:23 PM

Re: who won tonite on American Idol?

I thought they were both the best. I think Fantasia has a great voice, its different. I don't think she sounds like Macy Gray although they have a similar style. Diana is so good, I can't believe she's only 16. She may go all the way. I can definitely see her winning.
Octbride03 I don't know what you mean about the judges. Maybe people are influenced by the judges opinions but its the public that votes. All of them can sing, its just what appeals to you more. I'm not trying to fight about it, I just always find it strange when people say that so and so should have won. They all have the same potential to win, it comes down to the votes.