Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

Original post by bluegreen08

Nov 12, 2007 11:35 AM

I remember a post a while back about someone finding out their e-ring wasn't a real diamond and there were a number of reactions. Many people said it wasnt the fact that the ring wasn't a diamond, but that the girl's FH lied to her.

What if your FH lied, but to a lesser extent. Ex: what if your FH bought a ring on ebay, in a regular jewelry store, or somewhere else but lied to you and told you it was from Tiffany's? Now obviously it's not important for an e-ring to be from Tiffany's, HW, Cartier or any other 'name' shop. However, your FH lied to you about it.

Would you want to know? Would you be upset? Would you tell a friend if she was in that situation? Would you feel differently if FH lied to you about the quality of the stone as opposed to where he bought it?

(Disclaimer: I'm not in this situation -- FH and I picked out my ring together and it's not from Tiffanys -- but the boards are slow today. I was inspired by all of the 'Tiffany's' boxes for sale on ebay, and the 'Tiffany's style' rings offered by most jewelers that look similar but are clearly not the same delicate curved setting)

Saram Posted: Nov 12, 2007 12:40 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

i would be mad

babieblueeyez96 Posted: Nov 12, 2007 12:59 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

id be pissed that he lied!!! lol, who cares where the ring is from!!!

ChristineAaron08 Posted: Nov 12, 2007 01:19 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

nah, i wouldnt be pizzed- i would call him a moron for lying, but thats cuz i dont care if its tiffanys

GinaBambina08 Posted: Nov 12, 2007 01:43 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

I would be upset that he lied, but I honestly wouldn't be furious....I would be really mad at him initially, but it would wear off fairly quickly..

MAY24BRIDE Posted: Nov 12, 2007 01:55 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

I'd be upset that he felt he had to lie to me about it.

AS Posted: Nov 12, 2007 01:56 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

Tiffany, no tiffany I wouldnt really care. Maybe he lied for the good not for the bad.

SAMORY Posted: Nov 12, 2007 01:59 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

I would be very upset because I would feel like he should know me better than to lie to me about something as silly as that.

angl2001 Posted: Nov 12, 2007 03:00 PM

Re: Would you be mad if your FH lied to you about buying your ring from Tiffanys?

i would rather not know lol but if they girl is high mantinence and he felt her had to say he bought it there to make her happy then i understand why he did it...i know a girl who told her FH not to even think about propsong unless it was a specific ring that she herself picked out.