I LOVED this week's genre--I love Billy Joel, although I must say he looked realllllly old in the interivews--o well! He's still the best!
Kimberly C--horrible--she needs to go-her time is up.....
Ruben--he was good as usual--I think I've seen him do better. Simon's comment was uncalled for--he looked cute though!
Kimberely L--she really grew on me-she looked beautiful tonight and sounded the best I think I've ever heard her--I doubt she will be in the bottom 3 tomorrow night.
Josh Gracin-he was good--
Clay--adorable & amazing as always--Simon's comment was interesting...
Trenyce--eh--she bothers me a little--she wasn't that good tonight
Carmen-she will definetely be eliminated this week-she sounded horrible but I felt so bad for her-they all just dumped on her--I think she needs to grow a little more thick skinned for the business-she looked like she was going to cry hysterically! Don't get me wrong-I would've too-but you can't be like that in entertainment!
Sage10.03
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
MISTY....Great points!!! Kelly and Justin are HUGE DORKS and Rueben is awesome!
HeatherandNick
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
Go Misty!!!
Thrilled
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
Misty, I couldn't agree more. Billy has always been my boy and will continue to be, no matter how many times he wraps his car around a tree or moans on national television that he can't get laid.
I also agree that Ruben deserves a deal independent of this stupid show. Where are Justin and Kelly now? Not too many places....
HappyEverAfter
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
Is it just me, or is Clay really Rick Astley trying to revive his career? Seriously, everytime he sings I cannot concentrate on how he sounds, I keep wondering how that voice comes out of that body.
Did anyone notice the cowboy/Marine sang the wrong words in the opening part of Piano Man??? I mean, if you are going to sing Billy Joels best known song, at least get the words right.
Do the contestants pick the songs they sing? Or their outfits? B/C I spend half the show wondering what were they thinking???
endlessluv429
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
Adrienne --I think they get advised and choices on their outfits--but as far as josh messing up the words--he did it on 'purpose' all the contestants rearrange the songs because they only have a certain amount of time---i agree with you though I thought @ first he messed it up, but it did sound stupid in any event!
HappyEverAfter
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
oh, ick I did not like it. It sounded weird, like he forgot the words.
kptoys
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
Thrilled - Im LMAO at you. I totally agree with Clays whole thing he has going on.
I also agree with whoever said something about the faces Josh makes. He looks constipated when he is singing...
Carmen HAS GOT TO GOOOOO!!!
Jen2704
Posted:
Member since
Re: American Idol
I wish someone would have done Uptown Girl...love that song!! Yep, its Carmens time to go!!!
