Did my tasting...

I am freaking out. So I went for my tasting yesterday with FH, FH's parents and my parents. They gave us three entrees that they were serving for the wedding last night to sample. We got a stuffed chicken, a filet, and a mahi mahi. So the filet and mahi mahi were IMO dry and not as good as I thought they should be. The chicken was good and was very moist. Everyone that I was with had the same opinion on the food.

So now I am unsure what to do. FFIL is really into food and probably has one of the best palates I have ever seen, but seems to think that if we keep it simple with our menu that we will be okay. We are doing grand reception menu which is 4 dinner stations and CH with 8 passed h'or doeurves so I think we should be able to keep everything basic and simple. I did book contingent on tasting but now I am not sure if I should look elsewhere. FH and I love the place but I just can't seem to get past this. FH wants to keep it where we booked but I am really nervous. I also don't know if it was just our food because I saw that it was sitting out before they served it. What do you all think?