Okay I have not been to THAT many weddings but here goes...
My first ever was at The Miller Place Inn (after it was renovated from what it was years ago). This was in July of 2002. The cocktail hour was good and the service was just okay. The room I felt was too small and the ceiling was very, very low. The room also had very gaudy, IMO, decor--like a lion on the wall with water coming out of it's mouth, odd to me b/c the decor of that room did not match the cottage, antique look of the Miller Place Inn at all. The main dinner was not too good, the fish I had smelled fishy and I did not want to eat it. We did have a good time though b/c her DJ was very good, sorry I don't remember the name of the DJ!
My second wedding was at Giorgio's which was a step up from the first so that was nice! My cousin got married there and I had been there for dinner two times before the wedding. The second time I went for dinner it was great but they seemed to have a bit of a fruit fly problem that made me worried for my cousin. I mean, it was bad, there were flies everywhere and in our food--that we had to return as a result. My bf at the time was appalled, being a restaurant manager. He complained and they were very nice about it, the staff seemed so frustrated themselves with the fact that no matter how hard they tried they could not control it. They stated that it was an on-going problem that they called professionals in about but whatever they were doing was not working. I feel they should have comp'd our meal but they did not, they just offered free dessert that we took but could not eat b/c it was just loaded with flies... it seems that it got worse the more the dinner went on. My bf at the time was so fed up he said, 'it's okay, I'll just pay and we'll leave, it's our anniversary, they are nice about it-I just don't think they know what to do.' (The first time we went there was for Valentine's Day, winter of course, and everything was fabulous.) The fly incident was in September, maybe it's a seasonal thing? But luckily there were NO flies in July at my cousin's wedding. The cocktail hour was GREAT, lots of good food. My main meal was chicken which was very dry so I did not eat it. It's a shame but that stuff happens sometimes. I was full from the CH so I didn't mind too much. The service was good, helpful and very friendly. At the end when everyone was saying goodbye a BAT flew in an open door and was flying around the main room which was a little freaky, lol. that's a funny 'guess what happened at my wedding' story for my cousin (she probably does not think it is funny at all-the way she is). All in all, it was a nice wedding for the place but I did not like a lot of my cousin's choices (like her music) which was very blah and boring so no one really danced and my bf at the time and I were very bored... but that has nothing to do with Giorgio's of course.
The third wedding I went to was at the Watermill. It was in October and it was VERY cold. I don't know why the BM allowed this but the B&G chose to have an outdoor cocktail hour at 7:30pm. Okay, pitch black and FREEZING. The chairs and tables are all stone and they were SO cold you couldn't even sit. I remember going into my bf and the time's car and waiting for it to be over with the heat on. IMO the BM should not have allowed that, it was the middle of October and a CH outside at night with no other back-up plan if the weather was too cold is just too risky. It wasn't even like we had a room and outside area, it was just outside! When we were about to head to the main room an entire bridal party cut through the CH, another bride and her BM's. During the main part the food was just okay. I didn't eat much at this wedding--- at either the CH (in the car b/c of cold) or the main meal b/c it just did not taste good unfortunately. The couple that got married were friends of my BF's at the time and their taste was not so good, not that that has anything to do with the place but ya know. The service was friendly that time but I went there this year for New Year's Eve and two people in particular were extremely rude to me and my FH with remarks that were not nice and not in a nice tone either. All in all, it was just another wedding but the CH being too cold was just terrible and with all the other weddings going on that you could see just put a damper on it for me.
The most recent wedding I went to was at The Westbury Manor (same owners as The Watermill--odd, but the food was outstanding at this wedding). I guess sometimes things just happen and it is hit or miss. The WManor did have the same problem as the Wmill with the other weddings going on--the staff did not watch to make sure that the wedding's stayed seperate and we had crashers... several people from other weddings came into my friend's wedding. I do have to say though that the MD was superb, I saw him catch everything and handle every detail. He was very good. The CH was nice, the room was a little warm because there were so many people, I think they shouldn't have let that many people in that room. The food was very, very good at the CH and I ate my entire main meal of stuffed shrimp that was EXCELLENT. The music was nice, this B&G had pretty good taste in things so we had a nice time. I just think if WManor and Wmill are going to have that many weddings going on at once they need to keep them seperate more... we should have never had crashers and the main area was just FLOODED with 4 different wedding's guests and at one point two brides and their BP, yikes!
All in all, that's my HONEST opinion. I always try to include the positive and negative so that future bride's can get a valid review.
Good Luck everyone!
![]()