Post New Topic

Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

Original post by soontobecruz

I can't believe it but the church we had booked renovated and it looks terrible! I was there today and left cring. I won't even get into what they did bc if anyone else is using them and likes it I don't want to offend.

Anyway it was a Lutheran Church as I am Lutheran. FH is Catholic so we are in search of another church near JT (basically within a 15 minute drive or so)

So here is my MOST important question!! Can I a confirmed Lutheran get married in a Catholic church without having to convert. I would be more than happy to get married in one as long as I don't have to give up my religion.

Anyone with info please help!!

soontobecruz Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

Omg thank you all so much!! Since I saw my church at 5:00 I was dying to get on LIW bc I knew you would all have answers for me. I feel better already. I am gonna be a busy bee tomorrow trying to set up church appointments.

Thanks again ladies sooo much!!
Lu2700 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

FH is a baptized and confirmed catholic, and i'm christian, not baptized or confirmed....and we're getting married at st. pats.

they said as long as 1 of us a baptised catholic, its ok. we were even given the option to have a full mass, since FH has been a member of the church all his life (we opted out of it tho). our pastor did have to go about it with us labeled as an inter-faith marraige....not a fan of that part, but whatever.
laurenandmike618 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

Oh my gosh Shauna that is AWFUL!!!! Don't cry though - you CAN get married in the Catholic church!! I took my FOCCUS 'test' on Saturday and there was a section for interfaith couples so they definitely allow it. You will find a place. How about Matt's parish??

To answer your other question... donations vary. We have to pay over $1K.
JoanneAndJustin Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

One: Yes. you can get married in the RC church since Mike is a confirmed catholic.

My church's 'donation' is 800.00.

St. Edward's in Syosset is pretty lax, and I'm sure they'll marry you.

There's St. Brigid's in Westbury too.
stinenandy2010 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

Yes you can get married in a Catholic Church if you are another religion. However, a lot of churches will ask you to sign this document, basically stating you are another religion and I **think** it says something about raising your family Catholic.

MrsL2010 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

i know St. Catherine's in franklin square (my church - if you want pics, let me know - the donation i think was right around $600) will marry you if you are a non-parishoner - the priest who is doing my ceremony told us that.

there is also St. Thomas in West Hempstead, Holy Spirit (straight down Jericho Turnpike) and Notre Dame, both in New Hyde Park
meganbrandon Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

yeah, you can get married in a catholic church. my FH is baptist and i'm catholic so I had to sign something saying i will raise my kids catholic but he didnt have to make any promises. I even told my priest when i signed it that we've been going to a lutheran church lately b/c thats the only 1 we found in Virginia that we liked and if i had a kid today i would at least get them baptized catholic but in 5 years from now that might not be the case. He was cool with that answer! Hope this helps!

Lsorrent Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by stinenandy2010

Yes you can get married in a Catholic Church if you are another religion. However, a lot of churches will ask you to sign this document, basically stating you are another religion and I **think** it says something about raising your family Catholic.



Yup, the 'permission slip.' We had to do that. There is a section about raising your children Catholic, but FH and I left that part blank and didn't sign it and we still got our approval to get married.


Oh and Joanne - Shauna's FH is Matt....mine is Mike
Spring143 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

dont feel bad, i have to change churches too.
hope everything works out
soontobecruz Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by laurenandmike618

Oh my gosh Shauna that is AWFUL!!!! Don't cry though - you CAN get married in the Catholic church!! I took my FOCCUS 'test' on Saturday and there was a section for interfaith couples so they definitely allow it. You will find a place. How about Matt's parish??

To answer your other question... donations vary. We have to pay over $1K.



Thank Lau- Yea I assumed they vary. No biggie about that though. Matt's church is all the way in Hampton Bays and to go all the way east to head all the way West would be insane!! His original church in NJ where he grew up is STUNNING! I wish we could relocated the whole church here! LOL

Thanks again
soontobecruz Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by Lsorrent


Posted by stinenandy2010

Yes you can get married in a Catholic Church if you are another religion. However, a lot of churches will ask you to sign this document, basically stating you are another religion and I **think** it says something about raising your family Catholic.



Yup, the 'permission slip.' We had to do that. There is a section about raising your children Catholic, but FH and I left that part blank and didn't sign it and we still got our approval to get married.


Oh and Joanne - Shauna's FH is Matt....mine is Mike



Good to know! I have no problem signing something that says I am not a Catholic I don't know about me signing to promise I will raise them Catholic. If Matt had to sign it fine or if we couldleave it blank even better

Oh and Yupp he's a Matthew, not a Mike
Soon2bShea Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

Yes you can get married at the Catholic church!

Sorry I can't help with churches in that area though
laurenandmike618 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by soontobecruz


Posted by laurenandmike618

Oh my gosh Shauna that is AWFUL!!!! Don't cry though - you CAN get married in the Catholic church!! I took my FOCCUS 'test' on Saturday and there was a section for interfaith couples so they definitely allow it. You will find a place. How about Matt's parish??

To answer your other question... donations vary. We have to pay over $1K.



Thank Lau- Yea I assumed they vary. No biggie about that though. Matt's church is all the way in Hampton Bays and to go all the way east to head all the way West would be insane!! His original church in NJ where he grew up is STUNNING! I wish we could relocated the whole church here! LOL

Thanks again




Ohhhh yeah... DUH!!! Of course you can't go all the way out to Hampton Bays lol how dumb am I????
Jenna_and_John Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

Omgggggggggg I am sooo sorry, gosh you were so excited this is terrible. Unfortunately I do not have an answer to your dilemma but will keep my eyes and ears open and lots of and your way!!! You know we always say it, everything happens for a reason, hang in there!
Jenna_and_John Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by JoanneAndJustin

One: Yes. you can get married in the RC church since Mike is a confirmed catholic.

My church's 'donation' is 800.00.

St. Edward's in Syosset is pretty lax, and I'm sure they'll marry you.

There's St. Brigid's in Westbury too.



I was going to suggest this church but I heard if you are a nonparishioner they don't let you book the church until 6 months before the wedding. Not the end of the world but something to consider.
AdriandSteve Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

You got FM.

Mrs Z To Be Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

I sent you FM.
soontobecruz Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by Jenna_and_John


Posted by JoanneAndJustin

One: Yes. you can get married in the RC church since Mike is a confirmed catholic.

My church's 'donation' is 800.00.

St. Edward's in Syosset is pretty lax, and I'm sure they'll marry you.

There's St. Brigid's in Westbury too.



I was going to suggest this church but I heard if you are a nonparishioner they don't let you book the church until 6 months before the wedding. Not the end of the world but something to consider.



Good to know thanks!
HisFiance10 Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!

FH and I are both Catholic but everyone here says you can get married at a catholic church. Were getting married at ST. Matthias In ridgewood queens and its absolutly gorgeous. Theres some pics here for you to see. Im not sure how far away it is from JT but the donation fee is only $500

HTH
soontobecruz Posted:

Re: Church EMERGENCY HELP!!!!


Posted by HisFiance10

FH and I are both Catholic but everyone here says you can get married at a catholic church. Were getting married at ST. Matthias In ridgewood queens and its absolutly gorgeous. Theres some pics here for you to see. Im not sure how far away it is from JT but the donation fee is only $500

HTH



OMG that is amazing!!! IDK how far that is either but I am all the way at exit 68 on the LIE so Queens is pretty far. That church is gorgeous! Congrats on getting married there!!!

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.