reception venues - advice?

Hello,
This weekend I am looking at:

Timber Point CC
Captain Bills
Bellport CC
Vineyard Caterers
Atlantica

I LOVE Atlantica but don't know if I can swing it financially. I'd love to hear from anyone that has info/advice on any of these places!

If you don't want to post you can forum mail me instead.

Thanks!!

Re: reception venues - advice?

Re: reception venues - advice?

you can still receive private 'forum mail' via this website....just click 'forum mail' under a thread you want to reply to privately and it sends the person forum mail....you can also check your forum mail by clicking on forum mail at the top of your screen and you can see your inbox....hope this makes sense....

Re: reception venues - advice?

I love Atlantica, too!

Re: reception venues - advice?

I've been to a wedding at these places...

Timber Point CC - nice, small, food was OK
Captain Bills - very pretty, simple, food was great
Bellport CC - pretty, simple, beautiful grounds, food was delicious

Never went to a wedding at...Vineyard Caterers

Atlantica - was very interested in Atlantica, after seeing pics in a magazine and online. We visited...it's a small venue, wasn't impressed with the decor - the best part of the place, IMO, was the view. Breathtaking.

Good luck!

Re: reception venues - advice?

My cousin got married at the Bellport CC 10 years ago, and my family still talks about how great the cocktail hour was.

Re: reception venues - advice?

I just got married at Timber Point...I have pictures of the new renovations and my review is on the review board on page 2....

Re: reception venues - advice?

check out these links:

timber point thread

TP renovations

another TP bride

MY Timber Point Review

Re: reception venues - advice?

I'm getting married at the Bellport CC in Nov. They're just finishing redoing part of it- added a new bridal suite and tons of windows in the front.

It really is beautiful and they are VERY accommodating to deal with. The food is really yummy too... :)

FM me if you want more specifics- I got 'em.

Happy hunting!

Re: reception venues - advice?

Timber Point CC - Lessings Family- my sister and friend were given quotes, when they went to book, it was much higher.
Captain Bills- No first hand info
Bellport CC- Ate at the resturant, it was very nice BUT above the room where a party was. My chair was vibrating.
Vineyard Caterers- No first hand info
Atlantica- My cousin got married there, I thought it was overrated for the price, and I didn't think the food was that good. The only thing served at the CH was a raw bar- that could have been her choice but still.

Re: reception venues - advice?

Vineyard Caterers - Well Im getting married there in 23 days!!! HOLY CRAP!! Anyway. I think its beautiful. I have had nothing but an excellent experience with all the people there. They are willing to help in any way they can. The food is EXCELLENT!!! I have friends whove been there for other events and have raved about the food. Its one wedding at a time. The grounds are very nice as well. Can you tell I love the place.

Atlantica - I was there Oct 2002. My cousin got married there. Honestly I thought it was a beautiful location but the chairs had stains on them, the windows were dirty. I know you are on the ocean but someone needed to take a hose and a squigie to it. I thought the food was good. And for a beach wedding... it cant be beat. But for the price, it wasnt for me.

Re: reception venues - advice?

Oh man, try for Atlantica! That's where I really really wanted but I knew it couldn't happen with our budget. Good luck!!

Re: reception venues - advice?

I had my engagement party at the Bellport CC. It was fantastic!!! What a beautiful place. Good luck on your search.

Re: reception venues - advice?

Thanks, everyone! I'm looking forward to seeing all of these places. Most of the weddings I've been to recently have been out of town.

It's helpful for me to know what other people think, since I want my guests to enjoy it as well (and from what I hear I won't be doing much eating on the big day anyway!)

Congrats to all of you on your weddings!!!

Re: reception venues - advice?

Good luck with your decision and have fun checking out these places.

I can only give advice on Atlantica as we were married there this past September. They now have white chair covers so there are no stains on the chairs and I certainly didn't notice dirty windows if there were any!! We had three stations at cockatil hour and my guests raved about the food. I absolutley loved Atlantica and would recommend it to anyone. Yes, its pricey - but IMO, you get what you pay for!

Here's a pic of the inside:


and the outside:

Re: reception venues - advice?

i went to a wedding at captain bills in oct 2003-the place is nice and the food was good- only complaint it was chilly out for october and they didnt have the heaters on in the cocktail hour room-everyone was freezing- we actually had to ask the place to put on the heat-

also- we used to dock our boat there and people were having there cocktail hour and here we are with our dogs in shorts and bathing suits with the boats motor running which was extremely loud- if you dont mind that then the place was really nice- i do remember the shrimp appetizer was excellent-they also have a no shot policy a lot of the people at this wedding were very irritated by this but if you dont have big drinkers then it may not be a problem-

just my opinion hope it helps

Re: reception venues - advice?

I love Captain Bills ( SO NICE!!) and love Vineyards TOO! Atlantica is amazing but expensive...I loved Watermill as you can see...but also I loved Port Jeff CC...

Re: reception venues - advice?

I am getting married at BCC in Oct. The people there are amazing to deal with - very accommodating to anything you ask for. The grounds are beautiful, being on the golf course, but it looks even more beautiful at night. And we have heard so many wonderful things about the place.