Hotel for OTT guests - Wingate or Hilton?

If anyone has any experience with either hotel (Wingate in Garden City) or Hilton Garden Inn (Westbury) I'd appreciate it.

The Wingate has a bridal suite, Hilton doesnt
Hilton has an indoor pool, Wingate doesnt
Wingate has free continental bkfast, Hilton doesnt
Hilton has pretty lobby with fireplace, Wingate's lobby is ok but not as pretty
Wingate has a bar, Hilton doesnt (they dont have their liquor license yet)

Wingate is $129, Hilton is $139

Neither has shuttle service
Both will give OTT gift baskets if I provide them

Any info is appreciated.
Thanks