Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

there are some things i dont like about mine. i dont like the baguettes o nthe sides. i just want a simple skinny band with a big diamond. nothign on the sides.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

hmmm, once in a while I thnk it's too plain. But I picked it out. LOL! But usually I look at it and think its beautiful.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

lol youre too funny.
i didnt pick mine out but i told him what i wanted (which was different then what i would want now) but i NEVER said anything about baguettes... i hate tehm!

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I actually really have grown to love mine. It's the exact setting I wanted as a child (I am OBSESSED with diamonds) but once I got it I thought I would want it set higher...so glad I didn't because it looks beautiful with my wedding band being that it's set low...I also wanted a solitaire emerald cut...but 3 are better!

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

Hmmm, well I wouldn't say anything now. But on your anniversary you could possibly state how you love your ring, but that baguettes get snagged on things al ot and you wish you could get the same ring, but without the baguettes. Make it feel as if it's not his problem, but yours.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

lol he knows already... u know.. baguettes just dont sparkle!

Message edited 1/23/2005 5:11:15 PM.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by CubanBride

Hmmm, well I wouldn't say anything now. But on your anniversary you could possibly state how you love your ring, but that baguettes get snagged on things al ot and you wish you could get the same ring, but without the baguettes. Make it feel as if it's not his problem, but yours.

---

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

Baguettes are great...and they can sparkle, just clean your ring as often as possible (warm water and a drop or two of dishwashing liquid...or 2/3 warm water and 1/3 ammonia). My ring is emerald cut (which is similar to baguettes in that the lights is reflected like a mirror as opposed to other cuts) and as long as they're clear enough (quality wise) and clean...they'll sparkle. Once you wear it with your band you'll love it...plus, round solitaires are so common and you're not a common girl!

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I absolutely love mine. Even if it wasn't "exactly" what I wanted, I don't think I would ever sit there and nit-pick over this and that.

Its the thought that counts. JMO

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by JBKempf



Its the thought that counts. JMO

---

Message edited 1/23/2005 5:54:38 PM.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

To be honest, FH and I designed our ring but every now and again i look at it and kinda wish we had done something different...the diamond is channel set into a tension setting but it's not high...doesn't really do the diamond justice. I love the fact that mine is one of a kind and completely unique but I think in ten years I'll have it reset.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I know exactly how you feel. I'm overly picky and indecisive by nature so I still go back and forth on how I feel about my engagement ring. My fiance picked it out all by himself which I applude, however, I'm not sure if it's exactly what I would've chosen myself. It's a three stone ring with a radiant centerstone and radiant side stones on the side set in platinum. The diamonds are very sparkly but I sometimes wonder if the stones should be set higher and if the ring may be a little too simple. Then again, if he had chosen something too traditional or busy-looking, I would've found something to pick on...alas, I try not to obsess over it.

By the way, my sister wasn't crazy about her ring so her fiance went back to the jeweler and had her sidestones replaced...she's much happier now. I say, change the sides if you're really not happy with the way they look. Your fiance would probably prefer you being happy with your ring than for you to remain disappointed with some aspects of your current ring.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I love my e-ring-I had told my FH way before we got engaged that he'd better make sure the e-ring he got me was good because I was NEVER going to change it (his sisters all changed theirs and were talking about it at a family dinner once) I had shown him pics of what I wanted and his sister is a jeweler (so I made sure to tell her too!) She designed the ring off of pics I had shown my FH and I wouldn't change the ring for anything.

But, if you are unhappy with your ring-maybe for an anniversary you can get it changed to a new setting you love?! I'm sure your FH just wants you to love the ring considering he probably spent a fortune on it! IMO most guys would rather you be happy with it than want to change it and not do it and wont be upset if you want to-they usually just want you to be HAPPY

Message edited 1/24/2005 12:40:09 PM.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

The one complaint I have about mine (which I think I am going to get ridiculed for) is that I think the stone is too big for the setting. The setting is high and the stone keeps getting loose!!!!!!!!!!!! I have to keep going to the jeweler to have it reset. I am thinking about telling FH I want a 1.5 carat instead because its starting to get annoying and I am afraid I might lose the stone

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by Future_Mrs_B

The one complaint I have about mine (which I think I am going to get ridiculed for) is that I think the stone is too big for the setting. The setting is high and the stone keeps getting loose!!!!!!!!!!!! I have to keep going to the jeweler to have it reset. I am thinking about telling FH I want a 1.5 carat instead because its starting to get annoying and I am afraid I might lose the stone

---

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I love my e-ring most of the time!! Of course sometimesI wish the center stone was a little bigger, but aside from that it is exactly what I wanted!

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by jesslangen

I love my e-ring most of the time!! Of course sometimesI wish the center stone was a little bigger, but aside from that it is exactly what I wanted!

---

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I love my E-Ring! It's not what I thought I wanted, I wanted the baguets, but I have a classic solitaire setting that will never go out of style, and that I will always wear. The setting is cathedral, so that makes it not your everyday solitaire.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I had my ring reset back in October. The stone he purchased was flawless but the setting wasn't showing it off right and it wasn't what I wanted.

Don't be afraid to get it reset. My fiance is so happy now with the ring because it show cases my diamond so much better and because it makes me so happy.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by Sweetpea130000

I love my E-Ring! It's not what I thought I wanted, I wanted the baguets, but I have a classic solitaire setting that will never go out of style, and that I will always wear.

I felt the same about my simple solitaire, but it does sparkle and I get loads of compliments on it. FH got me a sapphire and diamond enhancer and now I love it both with and without the extra stones

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I have 3 tapered baguettes on each side of my ring and I love them! They get dirty very easily, but FH picked it out all by himself and I think that is what really matters! I wouldn't change my ring for anything.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by JBKempf

---

Posted by jesslangen

I love my e-ring most of the time!! Of course sometimesI wish the center stone was a little bigger, but aside from that it is exactly what I wanted!

---

Thats what anniversaries are for!!!

---

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

you know i just LOVE LIW! you can ask an honest question and get real answers, not 'flamed' as they say on the knot. i've seen this same question there, and the poor girl was just bombarded with unnecessary and rude comments.

and IMO try and wait it out perhaps you'll love it more with itme. my ring grew on me and now i like it. i didn't get to pick it out, but it took me awhile to be OK with that. its a gift, and i treat it as such.

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

---

Posted by IrishBride-05

---

Posted by Sweetpea130000

I love my E-Ring! It's not what I thought I wanted, I wanted the baguets, but I have a classic solitaire setting that will never go out of style, and that I will always wear.

I felt the same about my simple solitaire, but it does sparkle and I get loads of compliments on it. FH got me a sapphire and diamond enhancer and now I love it both with and without the extra stones

---

And now I can get a diamond wedding ring and it won't look like overkill!

Re: Horrible Thing to Ask, but does anyone NOT like their E-ring?

I love mine! It's a princess solitaire... There are times that I really want it with small, inset stones on the sides, which I might do eventually, but for now, I'm quite pleased!