Brides Helping Brides ™ - Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!UPDATE Pg 2

Post new topic

Wedding Forums > Brides Helping Brides ™ > Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!UPDATE Pg 2

Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!UPDATE Pg 2

BKtoLI Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:26 PM+

BKtoLI MEMBER SINCE: 6/05 TOTAL POSTS : 8517 WEDDING DATE: Apr 30, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:26 PM

Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!UPDATE Pg 2

I got 2 offers today out of 4 interviews that I went on....what are the odds???

And I still have about 6 more interviews scheduled for this week!!!

One is in the city and the other is about 20 minutes from my house. The city is willing to pay more and pays 100% for health insurance. The one by me covers 50% health insurance.

Both want to start me off on an hourly rate and then bring me up to salary. The city job said if I get another offer to let them know and they would make a counteroffer.

Both places want to know by tomorrow morning. Should I just pick one or keep going on interviews and tell them I need to wait?

I should say the salary difference right now is about $2500

beautyq115 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:28 PM+

beautyq115 MEMBER SINCE: 12/04 TOTAL POSTS : 16776 WEDDING DATE: Jul 16, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:28 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Thats a tough one Janna! But I am so happy for you!!

autumn Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:30 PM+

autumn MEMBER SINCE: 10/04 TOTAL POSTS : 3126 WEDDING DATE: Oct 07, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:30 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

congrats, what kind of job is it.

BKtoLI Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:33 PM+

BKtoLI MEMBER SINCE: 6/05 TOTAL POSTS : 8517 WEDDING DATE: Apr 30, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:33 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

The one in the city is a publishing firm, the one on LI is in manufacturing. It's a really hard toss up because while I miss working in the city, I know that it's a long (and expensive) commute.

Maybe it just boils down to where I see myself fitting in more.

The city job I would have my own office, the LI job I would be all over the place. I would also have to travel 4 Saturdays a year for auditing for the LI job.

Ugh decisions, decisions.....

Shorty McBride Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:35 PM+

Shorty McBride MEMBER SINCE: 4/05 TOTAL POSTS : 12785 WEDDING DATE: Nov 23, 2007

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 08:35 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

your post says crap... you need some monogrammed TP for the cleanup?

Seriously....congrats!

JanuaryBride06 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:00 PM+

JanuaryBride06 MEMBER SINCE: 4/05 TOTAL POSTS : 13015 WEDDING DATE: Jan 01, 1995

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:00 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

congratulatons!

Did the job in NYC mention anything like reimbursement for metrocard or for your monthly LIRR ticket or anything like that?

BKtoLI Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:01 PM+

BKtoLI MEMBER SINCE: 6/05 TOTAL POSTS : 8517 WEDDING DATE: Apr 30, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:01 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Posted by Shorty McBride

your post says crap... you need some monogrammed TP for the cleanup?

Seriously....congrats!

Thanks!!! I just wish this was an easier decision!!!!

MattsBride Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:03 PM+

MattsBride MEMBER SINCE: 11/05 TOTAL POSTS : 2925 WEDDING DATE: Jul 16, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:03 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

2 offers!! That's great! I know it's a tough decision, but you will find the job that's best for you. Congrats!!

Colleen1230 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:08 PM+

Colleen1230 MEMBER SINCE: 1/05 TOTAL POSTS : 335 WEDDING DATE: May 05, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:08 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Wow, that's great! Good for you!

BKtoLI Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:21 PM+

BKtoLI MEMBER SINCE: 6/05 TOTAL POSTS : 8517 WEDDING DATE: Apr 30, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:21 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Posted by JanuaryBride06

congratulatons!

Did the job in NYC mention anything like reimbursement for metrocard or for your monthly LIRR ticket or anything like that?

Not that I'm aware of!!! It's a small office, and I would probably be the only one who would need reimbursement.

I guess a lot of you ladies were right, though!!!

Had I never gone through the crap of being let go by my boss via IM, then I would not have this decision to make right now!!!

JanuaryBride06 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:24 PM+

JanuaryBride06 MEMBER SINCE: 4/05 TOTAL POSTS : 13015 WEDDING DATE: Jan 01, 1995

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:24 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Posted by BKtoLI

Posted by JanuaryBride06

congratulatons!

Did the job in NYC mention anything like reimbursement for metrocard or for your monthly LIRR ticket or anything like that?

Not that I'm aware of!!! It's a small office, and I would probably be the only one who would need reimbursement.

I guess a lot of you ladies were right, though!!!

Had I never gone through the crap of being let go by my boss via IM, then I would not have this decision to make right now!!!

They still might do metro card reimbursement in a smaller office but not mention it until you're actually working there.

I know the circumstances surrounding this job search s uck, but it sounds like you're going to have a great new place of employment very soon!

cmastro25 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:28 PM+

cmastro25 MEMBER SINCE: 7/04 TOTAL POSTS : 3838 WEDDING DATE: May 21, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:28 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Honestly when you boil it down to weekly/bi-monthly paychecks, $2500 is not a big difference, so I wouldn't let that play into your decision to much. I would say that convenience is a bigger factor than the money, but you really have to think about what you want. And if it's neither, then see if you can get an extension so you can go on the other interviews or take a gamble and turn them both down and keep looking.
What field are you in Janna? Teacher?

Goldi1021 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:31 PM+

Goldi1021 MEMBER SINCE: 1/05 TOTAL POSTS : 12766 WEDDING DATE: Feb 18, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:31 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Im proud of you Janna!!!

MrsStefan Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:34 PM+

MrsStefan MEMBER SINCE: 1/05 TOTAL POSTS : 5993 WEDDING DATE: Oct 14, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:34 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

WOW!!! 2 offers!! Thats great!! I would ask them to give you an extension until the end of the week. I think that if they want you that bad then they can hold the position PLUS, IMO, it shows your professionalism to the other companies that you have committed youself to for an interview. Its a tough decision. Having to work on the weekends would play a big role in my decision because I NEED my weekends in order to maintain some sanity. I dont think te 2500 would play that much into my decions because after they take out taxes and all that, its not all that much. GOOD LUCK!!! Let us know what you decide!!

LaurenluvsTJ Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:39 PM+

LaurenluvsTJ MEMBER SINCE: 1/05 TOTAL POSTS : 11866 WEDDING DATE: May 28, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:39 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Thats great, Janna!!
Its a tough decision, but make the one that feels right for you! A shorter commute isn't always the most important thing!

akajt98 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:40 PM+

akajt98 MEMBER SINCE: 2/05 TOTAL POSTS : 1498 WEDDING DATE: Feb 25, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:40 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

First off congrats. Second I would recommend not rushing into a decision. Try to figure out which places offers more of a future for you. Which company can you see yourself working in? Where do you think you fit?

As for the company that told you that if you get another offer to tell them and that they would counter offer....all I can say is they are obviously willing to pay you additional money so if you are interested make sure you counter offer. In fact it is a good idea to always counter offer. Never except the first....everything is always negotiable!

Best of luck and lets us know what you decide!

idovig Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:50 PM+

idovig MEMBER SINCE: 2/05 TOTAL POSTS : 1805 WEDDING DATE: Jul 22, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:50 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

WOW! good for you

mcb916 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:57 PM+

mcb916 MEMBER SINCE: 11/05 TOTAL POSTS : 1302 WEDDING DATE: Sep 16, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:57 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Posted by MrsStefan

WOW!!! 2 offers!! Thats great!! I would ask them to give you an extension until the end of the week. I think that if they want you that bad then they can hold the position PLUS, IMO, it shows your professionalism to the other companies that you have committed youself to for an interview. Its a tough decision. Having to work on the weekends would play a big role in my decision because I NEED my weekends in order to maintain some sanity. I dont think te 2500 would play that much into my decions because after they take out taxes and all that, its not all that much. GOOD LUCK!!! Let us know what you decide!!

I agree that you should go on the other interviews. You are in a GREAT position and you should use this opportunity to get yourself into the best position you can find (I'm sure you don't want to be doing another job search anytime soo, I know how much it *****!) You obviously have a lot to offer these companies if they are willing to make a counteroffer for you. Who knows what you may miss out on if you don't go to the interviews, you may find your dream job!!! Whatever you decide to do, best of luck!! Keep us posted...

BKtoLI Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:57 PM+

BKtoLI MEMBER SINCE: 6/05 TOTAL POSTS : 8517 WEDDING DATE: Apr 30, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 09:57 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Posted by cmastro25
What field are you in Janna? Teacher?

No, Office Management / Bookkeeping

The city job is for an Accounting Manager, the LI job is for a Bookkeeper. Technically, it's the same thing.

I realized that the LI job said they would probably require me to work OT on occasion. So in that respect, I would still get home at 6:30 - 7pm.

Should also mention the city job is a small office and the LI office is mid-size to large. My experience has mainly been in small offices. Also FH says maybe the city job would counteroffer with more money, which means that $2500 gap will become larger.

I wish there was an easy way to do this!!

cmastro25 Posted: Dec 05, 2005 10:00 PM+

cmastro25 MEMBER SINCE: 7/04 TOTAL POSTS : 3838 WEDDING DATE: May 21, 2006

Posted: Dec 05, 2005 10:00 PM

Re: Holy Crap!! I got 2 offers today!!!

Posted by BKtoLI

Posted by cmastro25
What field are you in Janna? Teacher?

No, Office Management / Bookkeeping

The city job is for an Accounting Manager, the LI job is for a Bookkeeper. Technically, it's the same thing.

I realized that the LI job said they would probably require me to work OT on occasion. So in that respect, I would still get home at 6:30 - 7pm.

Should also mention the city job is a small office and the LI office is mid-size to large. My experience has mainly been in small offices. Also FH says maybe the city job would counteroffer with more money, which means that $2500 gap will become larger.

I wish there was an easy way to do this!!

Don't laugh, but make a pro/con list. They work for me. Some pros might balance out a con and so forth. If you get it all out on paper to see it, it helps put things in perspective.