Looking for a place to have a rehearsal dinner!

Hi ladies,
Getting married over Memorial Day weekend this year. Everything is done (I'm an event planner) except one thing. I live in Baltimore but am from the Island originally. We're getting married in Port Jeff and I'm trying to find a place to have our rehearsal dinner. Idealy, I wanted to find a place I could rent where I could have a pizza party. Our weddding is very formal so I wanted the night before to be super casual. But I can't find any place and it's hard because I live in Baltimore. Anyone have any ideas about a place we could have a pizza party at near port jeff. or anyone have any ideas about a restaurant (italian, american) near port jeff where we could have the rehearsal dinner? Thanks so much for any help you can give.

Re: Looking for a place to have a rehearsal dinner!

I don't know if they do pizza; but Mario's in Setauket is nice.

Re: Looking for a place to have a rehearsal dinner!

I had my rehearsal dinner at Lombardi's on the Sound in Pt. Jeff. They did a fabulous job. The only thing is it is not as casual as a pizza place, but they have great Italian food and top notch service.

Re: Looking for a place to have a rehearsal dinner!

Portabella in Pt Jeff is awesome. They have great pizza too.

or Carnival Restaurant in Setauket(?) on Rt 347 also, nice restaurant & good pizza

Re: Looking for a place to have a rehearsal dinner!

'Pasta Pasta' is AWESOME in Port Jeff... the name doesn't sound like it would be a classy restaurant, but it is. And the food is OUTSTANDING.