Can Groomsmen Wear Suits Instead of Tuxedos? Long Island Wedding Style Tips

Jul 03, 2025 01:50 PM Back

When it comes to wedding attire, many Long Island couples are embracing flexibility and personal style — especially for the groomsmen. One common question grooms ask during the planning process is: Can my groomsmen wear suits instead of tuxedos? The answer is a resounding yes — and in many cases, it might even be the better choice.

Suits vs. Tuxedos: What’s the Difference?

A tuxedo is considered the height of formal evening wear, typically featuring satin details on the lapel and a stripe down the trouser leg. A suit, on the other hand, is slightly more casual, often made entirely from one fabric with a simpler design.

On Long Island, where weddings range from elegant waterfront affairs to rustic vineyard celebrations, the choice between suits and tuxedos often comes down to venue, season, and personal taste.

Why Suits Might Be the Right Choice for Your Long Island Wedding

1. Perfect for Outdoor or Daytime Ceremonies

Whether you're saying "I do" at a North Fork vineyard, a charming barn in the Hamptons, or a beachfront venue in Montauk, suits tend to look more natural in outdoor and daytime settings. They're less formal but still polished, especially when tailored well.

2. Comfort and Seasonality

Long Island summers can be hot and humid — and suits are typically lighter and more breathable than tuxedos. For spring and summer weddings, this can be a major comfort win for your groomsmen.

3. More Budget-Friendly

Renting or buying a suit is usually more affordable than a tuxedo. If you’re being mindful of your groomsmen’s budgets, suits are a thoughtful and stylish option — and they can be re-worn for other occasions!

4. Easier to Match Your Color Palette

Long Island weddings often reflect the natural beauty of the region — soft coastal tones, vineyard greens, and classic navy blues. Suits come in a wider range of colors and textures, giving you more flexibility to match your wedding theme.

5. Your Groom Can Still Stand Out

Worried about the groom blending in? Have him wear a slightly different shade, a three-piece suit, or unique accessories like a boutonniere, patterned tie, or pocket square to set him apart while keeping the look cohesive.

Long Island Wedding Suit Ideas for Groomsmen

Classic Navy or Gray Suits: Timeless and versatile for any venue from The Vineyards at Aquebogue to Westbury Manor.
Light Linen or Tan Suits: Perfect for beach weddings in Long Beach or Shelter Island.
Rustic Tweed or Earth Tones: Ideal for fall weddings at Long Island farms or barn venues.
Matching Accessories: Create a unified look with matching ties, socks, and shoes — or go mix-and-match for a modern twist.

Your wedding is about celebrating your love in a way that reflects you. Whether your groomsmen wear suits or tuxedos, the most important thing is that everyone feels comfortable, confident, and stylish.

Long Island offers a wide variety of venues and vibes, so trust your instincts and choose attire that suits the setting, the season, and your style. With the right fit and a little attention to detail, suits can absolutely look just as polished and wedding-worthy as tuxedos.

Photo Credit: Giorgenti