Hidden Gem Wedding Venues on Long Island You’ve Never Heard Of

Apr 27, 2025 10:05 PM Back

When it comes to planning a wedding on Long Island, many couples dream of a venue that feels truly unique — a hidden gem where their love story can unfold away from the usual crowds. If you're searching for off-the-beaten-path wedding venues on Long Island, you're in the right place! We've rounded up some of the most enchanting, lesser-known spots that offer beauty, charm, and unforgettable memories.

1. The Bellport Inn — Bellport Village

Tucked away in the historic Bellport Village on Long Island’s South Shore, The Bellport Inn offers a stunning backdrop for intimate weddings. This charming estate combines historic character with modern amenities, surrounded by lush gardens and cozy gathering spaces. It’s perfect for couples looking for a relaxed yet sophisticated vibe, just steps from the Great South Bay.

Why it's a hidden gem:
Private estate feel
Accommodations for wedding parties and guests
Elegant outdoor ceremony and reception spaces

2. The Boathouse Shelter Island

Shelter Island itself feels like a secret getaway, and The Boathouse elevates that vibe even further. Nestled in Coecles Harbor, this waterfront venue offers rustic charm with breathtaking water views. It's a dream location for a nautical, coastal-inspired wedding — accessible by ferry but far from ordinary.

Why it’s off-the-beaten-path:
Exclusivity — Shelter Island is a destination in itself
Historic boathouse architecture
Sunset ceremonies over the water

3. Peconic River Herb Farm — Calverton

For nature lovers, the Peconic River Herb Farm is a whimsical, romantic escape. This 14-acre property features gardens, greenhouses, and riverfront views, offering couples a truly rustic and botanical setting. Weddings here feel enchanted, surrounded by seasonal blooms and the scent of fresh herbs.

What makes it a hidden treasure:
Outdoor ceremonies among gardens and fields
Eclectic vintage décor available
DIY-friendly options for creative couples

4. Jedediah Hawkins Inn — Jamesport

Known for its stately 1860s architecture, the Jedediah Hawkins Inn is a historic inn surrounded by North Fork vineyards and farmland. With its lush gardens, barn spaces, and gourmet farm-to-table restaurant, it's ideal for an intimate wedding that feels luxurious yet welcoming.

Reasons it’s a best-kept secret:
Boutique hotel experience for guests
Award-winning cuisine
Vineyard sunsets and rustic-chic photo ops

5. Hallockville Museum Farm — Riverhead

Want a true slice of Long Island history? Hallockville Museum Farm offers 28 acres of preserved farmland, historic barns, and authentic 19th-century homesteads. It’s a one-of-a-kind venue for couples who love country charm, vintage weddings, and pastoral settings.

Why couples love this hidden gem:
Historic barn receptions
Open fields for ceremonies and tents
Picture-perfect farmstead backdrops

Why Choose a Hidden Gem Venue on Long Island?

Choosing a lesser-known venue isn't just about being unique — it's about creating a personalized experience. Hidden gems often offer more flexibility, privacy, and character than traditional wedding venues. Plus, your wedding photos will stand out with settings that feel fresh, intimate, and full of natural beauty.

Whether you’re dreaming of a rustic farm, a historic inn, or a waterside escape, Long Island’s secret venues offer endless possibilities to bring your wedding vision to life.

Pro Tip: These venues book up quickly (especially for spring and fall weddings), so don’t wait to schedule a tour!

Photo Credit: The Bellport Inn