Hidden Gem Wedding Venues on Long Island: Unique Locations for Your Dream Wedding

Mar 01, 2025 10:51 AM Back

When planning a wedding on Long Island, many couples envision grand ballrooms and waterfront estates. While these classic venues are stunning, there are also hidden gems that offer a unique and unforgettable setting for your big day. Whether you’re dreaming of an intimate garden celebration, a rustic barn wedding, or a historic mansion backdrop, Long Island has a variety of lesser-known venues that provide charm, character, and exclusivity.

1. The Boathouse Shelter Island
Tucked away on Shelter Island, The Boathouse is a secluded waterfront venue offering breathtaking views and a serene atmosphere. With its rustic-chic aesthetic, this venue is perfect for couples who want a romantic yet relaxed wedding experience. The natural beauty of Shelter Island and its exclusivity make it one of Long Island’s best-kept wedding secrets.

2. The Vineyards at Aquebogue
For couples seeking a countryside wedding with a touch of elegance, The Vineyards at Aquebogue is an exceptional choice. Nestled in Long Island’s wine country, this venue offers lush vineyards, stunning sunsets, and a sophisticated yet rustic ambiance. The combination of award-winning wines and scenic landscapes provides a magical setting for an unforgettable celebration.

3. The Bellport Inn
Located on Long Island’s South Shore, the Bellport Inn is a charming boutique venue perfect for intimate weddings. This historic property features beautiful gardens, cozy interiors, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. It is ideal for couples looking to host a smaller, personalized wedding with a touch of old-world elegance.

4. Flowerfield
Hidden in St. James, Flowerfield is a 56-acre estate that boasts orchards, vineyards, and picturesque gardens. The venue’s private island and tranquil pond create a fairytale-like atmosphere. Flowerfield’s breathtaking scenery and one-event-at-a-time exclusivity make it a hidden gem among Long Island wedding venues.

5. Sole East
For couples dreaming of a beachside wedding with a laid-back yet stylish vibe, Sole? East in Montauk is a fantastic choice. This boutique hotel offers lush gardens, fire pits, and an effortless coastal ambiance. With its relaxed yet chic aesthetic, Sole? East is perfect for a bohemian-inspired wedding by the beach.

6. Three Village Inn
Overlooking the scenic Stony Brook Harbor, Three Village Inn is a historic gem with charm and elegance. This venue blends colonial-era architecture, waterfront views, and cozy indoor spaces. The intimate setting and exceptional cuisine make it a perfect romantic Long Island wedding spot.

7. Westbury Manor
A true Gold Coast treasure, Westbury Manor provides a timeless setting for a sophisticated wedding. The five-acre estate features beautifully landscaped gardens, a conservatory, and elegant indoor spaces. Couples looking for a classic yet intimate wedding venue will find Westbury Manor to be an exquisite choice.

Why Choose a Hidden Gem Wedding Venue on Long Island?
Hidden gem wedding venues offer more than a beautiful setting—they provide an exclusive and personalized experience that ensures your wedding stands out. Many of these venues host only one wedding at a time, fully immersing couples in their special day without distractions. Additionally, these unique locations often allow for greater customization, making bringing your wedding vision to life easier.

Find Your Perfect Long Island Wedding Venue
If you’re looking for a unique and unforgettable wedding venue, Long Island has a wealth of hidden gems waiting to be discovered. From vineyards and waterfront estates to charming inns and rustic barns, these venues offer an intimate and picturesque setting for your special day. Start exploring these hidden treasures and create memories that will last a lifetime!

Need help finding the perfect venue or planning your dream Long Island wedding? Explore top-rated wedding vendors and services to bring your vision to life!

Location: The Boathouse Shelter Island
Photo Credit: North Island Photography